DEC Still Has Not Made Decision On Proposed 'Sand Land' Expansion In Noyac - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1411710

DEC Still Has Not Made Decision On Proposed 'Sand Land' Expansion In Noyac

icon 2 Photos

authorAlyssa Melillo on Mar 25, 2015

The State Department of Environmental Conservation has yet to make a decision on an application to expand a sand mine in Noyac, for which the department held a public hearing in November.

According to Aphrodite Montalvo, a DEC spokesperson, the department is still reviewing comments on the application from Wainscott Sand & Gravel Inc. to expand its mine on Middle Line Highway by 4.9 acres, as well as to excavate 40 feet deeper than authorized under its existing State Mined Lands Reclamation Act permit, which was issued in 2013 and expires in 2018.

In July, the DEC determined that the expansion of the mine, locally dubbed “Sand Land,” would have no adverse environmental effects, allowing Wainscott Sand & Gravel to bypass an expensive and time-consuming environmental review. Environmentalists, local officials and residents were quick to oppose the decision, though, writing a slew of letters to the department urging it to reconsider, as the mine sits above one of Suffolk County’s deepest aquifers.

Additionally, neighbors of Sand Land—The Bridge golf course being one of them—submitted complaints about noise from the number of trucks that visit the site, as well as smells from the composting and mulching that takes place there.

In response to the local reaction, the DEC held a public hearing on November 19 at the Bridgehampton Community House, led by DEC Administrative Law Judge Molly T. McBride. Opponents stressed that the expansion would compromise the quality of drinking water that comes from the aquifer, which supplies most of the drinking water in eastern Southampton and western East Hampton towns.

Ms. Montalvo said in an email last week that while at this point the department cannot provide an exact date for a decision, “any permits issued by the DEC would include conditions that require the applicants to avoid, minimize and mitigate adverse environmental impacts.”

This week, Wainscott Sand & Gravel President John Tintle said that while he has not heard from the DEC about the status of his application, it is not unusual for the department to take more than four months to make a determination. “This is kind of standard for the DEC to review mining modifications,” he said.

Mr. Tintle added that he does not understand why the community has suddenly become interested in his company’s mining operation, as it has been around for decades. But he assured that with the mine’s proposed expansion, there would still be a 100-foot distance between the new base of the mine and the start of the groundwater table, thus preventing contamination of drinking water with manganese and other heavy metals, as environmentalists have feared.

“The business has been mining there since the late ’50s, early ’60s, yet it’s never been a topic of the local [community],” Mr. Tintle said. “So I think that speaks to how we’ve been a good neighbor.”

But Robert DeLuca, president of the Group for the East End, said his organization has been keeping an eye on activity near the aquifer since the late 1980s, when there were talks of establishing a golf course where The Bridge now stands. He said the controversy surrounding the golf club is what led to the stringent environmental protocols it now has to follow, which includes regularly monitoring groundwater with 16 test wells.

He added that interest in Wainscott Sand & Gravel’s operations has grown because of the expansion application, as it is a chance to encourage the DEC to require more groundwater monitoring at the mine. There are currently two test wells on either side of the mine, one of which runs 150 feet deep from the base of the mine, Mr. Tintle has said.

“We’re just talking about getting a handle on all the environmental protocols. Our concern is that the DEC initially took the position that there’s no adverse environmental effects,” Mr. DeLuca said, noting that a comprehensive study conducted by the DEC in 2013 that examined groundwater monitoring wells at a composting site in Yaphank found them to be contaminated with manganese.

“We think there’s ample evidence,” he said. “If they’re continuing to look at [the comments from the public hearing], that’s fine by me. I would rather they take the time.”

You May Also Like:

Sotheby's and Town & Country Offices Host Coat Drives

Some South Fork real estate offices are serving as drop-off locations for coat donations to assist people in need. Sotheby’s International Realty is hosting a coat drive through the end of the year in partnership with Heart of the Hamptons in Southampton Village and the Sag Harbor Food Pantry. New and gently used winter clothes for all ages can be dropped off at the Sotheby’s offices located at 2446 Main Street, Bridgehampton; 6 Main Street, East Hampton; and 50 Nugent Street, Southampton. Town & Country Real Estate is accepting coats through December 1 at its offices: 46 Main Street, East ... 22 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

In Sagaponack, 1.7-Acre Property Sells for $7.65 Million

A 1.7-acre Sagaponack property with an existing house but coveted for the land itself recently ... 20 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

1930 Southampton Village Residence Sells for $6.75M

A south-of-the-highway Southampton Village shingled traditional recently sold for $6.75 million, having found a buyer ... by Staff Writer

Homeowners Insurance Becoming More Difficult and Expensive To Obtain on the East End

Location, location, location. We’ve each heard this phrase when it comes to establishing the value ... 14 Nov 2024 by Joseph Finora

Oneck Estate Sells for $7.9 Million

A Westhampton Beach estate that was completed in 2008 by Westhampton’s Sea Level Construction has ... 13 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

Governor Announces $10 Million Available To Advance Zero-Emission Homes

Governor Kathy Hochul announced last month that $10 million is now available to advance new zero-emission homes in New York State. The Building Better Homes – Zero Emission Homes for Healthier Communities program incentivizes the design, construction and marketing of new clean and resilient single-family homes and townhomes and provides training and technical support to builders and developers. Advancing zero-emission new construction across the state will reduce emissions, improve indoor air quality, and create healthy, comfortable and resilient living environments for all New Yorkers, according to the governor’s office. “New homes built to the latest clean energy and efficiency standards ... by Staff Writer

North Sea Beach Colony Modern Sells for ​​​​​​​$9.28 Million

A waterfront modern home in North Sea Beach Colony located about halfway between Cow Neck ... by Staff Writer

Amagansett Bell Estate Section Home Sells for $11 Million

In Amagansett North, a new build at 39 Timber Trail has sold for $11 million, ... 6 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

REI Hosts Fall Luncheon November 19: Communities Before and After Multifamily Development — Exploring Empirical Data

The Real Estate Institute at Stony Brook University College of Business will explore the evolving landscape of solutions to Long Island’s housing crisis during its fall luncheon, titled, “Communities Before and After Multifamily Development — Exploring Empirical Data.” Taking place on November 19 at Heritage Club at Bethpage, in Farmingdale, the event aims to bring together industry experts and thought leaders to share their perspectives on the future of multifamily development on Long Island and bring insight into the intricacies of Long Island’s success stories with multifamily development. “As housing paradigms shift, this event will dissect the emerging trends, technological ... 28 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Southampton Village Gambrel With Pool, Tennis Sells for $13.3 million

A gambrel-style residence in the Southampton Village estate section recently sold for $13.28 million. At ... 22 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer