Southampton Village ZBA Approves Mocomanto And Despatch Applications - 27 East

Southampton Village ZBA Approves Mocomanto And Despatch Applications

icon 2 Photos
Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village.

Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village. DCIM100MEDIADJI_0327.JPG

Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village.

Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village. DCIM100MEDIADJI_0344.JPG

authorGreg Wehner on Oct 27, 2017

Two highly scrutinized projects in the Southampton Village historic district were approved by the Village Zoning Board of Appeals on Thursday night, October 26.

After five years of going back and forth with an application to subdivide two properties at 550 and 554 Hill Street, which includes the former Despatch Self Storage site, sitting ZBA member and property owner James Zuhusky finally got the variances required to subdivide the 2.8 acres into three lots. The vote was unanimous, with Mr. Zuhusky excluded from the count.

Members of the ZBA on Thursday also approved a wetlands permit that allows Ken Fox—a managing partner at the Stripes Group who has been instrumental in financing companies like Blue Apron, GoFundMe and Grubhub—to move one step closer to nearly doubling the size of his century-old Victorian home on Lake Agawam at 472 First Neck Lane, known as Mocomanto.

Already handicapped because of board member Mr. Zuhusky’s absence, the board voted 3-1 in favor of the permit, with Kevin Guidera, Mark Greenwald and Dan Guzewicz voting to approve the application, and Rob DeVinney voting against.

Mr. Fox plans a 1½-story addition that would increase the gross floor area of the historic house by 52 percent, from 4,717 square feet to 7,190 square feet, which is 44 percent of the maximum allowed GFA of 16,071 square feet.

The existing home sits completely in the regulated wetlands setback area. The homeowner is proposing an “L-shaped” attachment, of which only 592 square feet of the footprint would fall within the regulated wetlands setback. A special exception permit authorizing building on the regulated wetlands area was required to construct the connector to the addition.

“The proposed design respects the environment by not extending the addition to the north, east or south of the existing residence in the wetland area but seeks to cross the regulated area through the connector,” the decision read.

Over the course of three hearings, neighbors, lawyers and environmental experts all provided statements, records and studies arguing why the project should, or should not, be approved.

The board noted in its decision the prominent arguments: that standards should be applied that are applicable to zoning variances for the permit; that the Southampton Village Board of Architectural Review and Historic Preservation should review the application before the ZBA rules; that a pool house on the property that was rebuilt in 2014 after the original burned down was illegally constructed with an extended patio; that the number of rooms needs to be reviewed for accuracy; and that underground leaching pools were installed, along with a driveway, without the necessary permits.

Ultimately, all of the arguments fell short with ZBA members, with the exception of the pool house and the leaching pools. For the wetlands permit to be issued, the owner is required to restore the pool patio to its original configuration, which Mr. Fox and his team have agreed to comply with. The board is also requesting that any leaching pools within the regulated wetlands setback be removed, and, according to Southampton Village-based attorney John Bennett, who is representing Mr. Fox, that won’t be an issue—because, he said, the leaching pools don’t fall within that setback.

The applicant also proposed a 40-foot wetlands buffer, which the board requested be extended to 50 feet.

Mr. Fox’s neighbor, Joyce Giuffra, voiced her concerns about the addition and the construction of the connector within the regulated wetlands setback. Now that it’s been approved by the ZBA, she said she is concerned that it will set a new precedent going forward.

“The ZBA majority ignored the strong opposition,” Ms. Giuffra said in an email, naming the Peconic Baykeeper, the Group for the East End, the Southampton Association and 1,000 signers of a petition, all of whom spoke against the project. “We’re hopeful that the Architectural Review Board will now take a very hard look at this massive addition, which will increase Mocomanto’s footprint by 175 percent.

“It would be tragic for our village if historic homes around Lake Agawam are turned into McMansions,” she added.

Ms. Giuffra said the addition would be right next to her children’s bedrooms, and that she is concerned about the increased noise and traffic on their small shared driveway.

As to the Despatch property, Mr. Zuhusky’s variances allow a subdivision creating three parcels that cover a total of 2.8 acres on a property that currently contains two houses as well as Despatch Self Storage—but a request to build guest homes on two of the properties was denied.

Mr. Zuhusky plans one half-acre lot and a pair of lots that would be about 1.1 acres each. A variance was required from the ZBA because the properties are in two separate zoning districts, requiring 1-acre and 3-acre residential lots.

Board members voted to approve the variances on the condition that Mr. Zuhusky use innovative alternative wastewater treatment systems approved by the Suffolk County Department of Health Services for each property. Mr. Zuhusky also is required to have the nonconforming buildings on the property demolished.

“It is indisputable that the nonconforming industrial storage/warehouse use and the long, narrow nonconforming lots are incompatible with the current residentially zoned neighborhood,” the decision read. It went on to say that what was being proposed was compatible with the character of the neighborhood.

The project was criticized during the application process—which began in August 2012—by neighbors because of the proposed density, as well as Mr. Zuhusky’s proposal going before a board on which he sits. The decision notes that Mr. Zuhusky recused himself from the proceedings each time the application was brought up.

“Mr. Zuhusky did not personally appear before the board, and all presentations on the matter were made by the applicant’s agents,” the decision noted.

You May Also Like:

Ponquogue Bridge Ordered Closed by State DOT After Inspection Reveals Concerns About Concrete

The New York State Department of Transportation has ordered Ponquogue Bridge in Hampton Bays closed ... 21 Feb 2025 by Michael Wright

Youth Bureau Basketball Tournament Registrations Being Accepted

The Southampton Town Youth Bureau will host its annual 3-on-3 Basketball Tournament on Friday, March 14, from 7 to 10 p.m. at Southampton Youth Services, 1370A Majors Path in Southampton. Sign-in and warm up drills will start at 6 p.m.. The tournament is open to students in grades five to 12, and prizes will be awarded to the winning teams in middle and high school brackets. Space is limited and team pre-registration of $45 is required by Monday, March 10. Each team member must submit a completed registration form along with payment ($15/player) to the Southampton Youth Bureau, located at ... by Staff Writer

Quogue Library To Host Gardening Series

The Quogue Library will hold a series of gardening programs this spring with presenter Mariah Whitmore. The first, on Saturday, March 8, from 3 to 4 p.m., will offer “Common Sense Landscape Tips,” including correct tree and shrub planting, preventing deer browsing and managing water, among other topics. ⋅ “Plants You Have (Likely) Never Heard Of” is up next on April 5, from 11 a.m. to noon, and will focus on overlooked, underappreciated, or unknown trees, shrubs, perennials, annuals and vines that thrive on Long Island. May 3 brings “Pollinator Garden and Wildlife Landscapes” from 3 to 4 p.m. The ... by Staff Writer

Hampton Photo Arts Consolidates to Southampton Location, Expands Capacity for Larger Art Projects

Hampton Photo Arts and Framing has closed its longtime Bridgehampton location and now only will ... by Dan Stark

Jamie M. Ottati of Hampton Bays Dies February 18

Jamie M. Ottati of Hampton Bays died peacefully at her home on February 18. She ... by Staff Writer

Kiwanis To Host Bingo Fundraiser

The Kiwanis Club of Southampton Town will host a St. Patrick’s Day bingo fundraiser on Friday, March 14, from 6 to 9 p.m. at the Hampton Bays American Legion Hall, 55 Ponquogue Avenue. Proceeds from the event will help pay for ingredients used in the soups Kiwanis members make for the food pantry. Admission is $30 per person includes two boards and snacks with a cash bar. Extra cards will be available for $10 to share the wealth. To purchase tickets, go to kiwanisclubofsouthamptontown.org. by Staff Writer

Grand Jury Indictment in Violent Robbery of Flanders Deli

The Suffolk County district attorney’s office this week announced that it has filed felony assault charges against the Farmingville man who police have said robbed a Flanders Road deli last September and “pistol whipped” a female clerk with the butt of a handgun multiple times. District Attorney Ray Tierney said that Demario Weston, 22, has exhibited “a disturbing pattern of criminal conduct” in announcing the felony indictment against Weston and his girlfriend, Tiana MacDonald, 24, who was also arrested when police raided their Farmingville apartment in January and found a large quantity of drugs, including fentanyl, that police said the ... 20 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer

Update: Accident Occurred During Scheduled Maintenance, Compounding East End Power Outage

Update Friday, February 21: Power Line Maintenance Work That Was Underway When Box Truck Took ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of February 20

HAMPTON BAYS — An East Quogue man reported to Southampton Town Police that someone stole his e-bike from outside a Montauk Highway business on February 10. The man said the bike was parked at the business at 6:30 a.m. and when he returned shortly after noon it was gone. Police have identified a Southampton resident as a suspect in the theft but no charges have been filed yet. RIVERSIDE — An employee at the 7-Eleven convenience store on Flanders Road told Southampton Town Police that a white man wearing a red jacket, denim jeans, Nike sneakers and a black scarf, ... 19 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer

Jonathan Swezey Raynor of Remsenburg Dies February 6

Jonathan Swezey Raynor, a devoted husband, father, grandfather, brother, teacher, and mentor, passed away on February 6, 2025, at the Kanas Center for Hospice Care in Quiogue. He was 74. Jonathan was born on March 30, 1950, the son of Robert Clinton Raynor and Dorothy Raynor (née Swezey). He was raised in Remsenburg and graduated from Westhampton Beach High School before attending SUNY Oswego, where he met the love of his life, Elizabeth “Betsy” Gaylord. The two married in 1973 and shared a lifetime of love and partnership until Betsy’s passing from glioblastoma in March of last year. A lifelong ... by Staff Writer