Commitment - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1361822

Commitment

icon 13 Photos

authorMichelle Trauring on Feb 12, 2013

It was 1963 and Phyllis Sonnenberg was expecting a proposal.

In a matter of days, her Wall Street boyfriend, Bill, was to board a plane bound for Argentina, where she annually visited her family, and ask for her hand in marriage.

At the last minute, he “freaked,” she chuckled during a telephone interview last week.

“He saw a wedding scene on television and decided he couldn’t handle it,” she recalled. “I said, ‘That’s a bummer, but I still have Charlie.’”

Charles Rosenthal was Bill’s colleague who double-dated with the couple for more than a year. When Mr. Rosenthal heard about the breakup, he took her out to cheer her up.

And he brought along a rose.

“We knew each other and we were familiar with each other,” he said. “We knew our habits, et cetera. So the getting-to-know-you business had long passed.”

The couple was married within a few months, which Ms. Rosenthal says was “obviously the right move,” even though the pair have opposite tastes. Mr. Rosenthal loves skiing and tennis, and his wife prefers the theater and art galleries to sports. She is happy to stay at their home in Manhattan, while he can be found at their second home in East Hampton on nature walks.

Despite their differences, Mr. Rosenthal can’t imagine his life without her.

“I was with him when he was supposed to go to [Argentina] and I was trying to encourage him because his mother wanted him to do that, too,” Mr. Rosenthal said of his wife’s ex-boyfriend. “I think he really wasn’t ready to get married and he was just afraid of it, and some people are. Some people are scared to make the commitment.”

But the Rosenthals weren’t. And neither are the 36 other pairs featured in Sagaponack-based photographer Morton I. Hamburg’s newest release, “Commitment,” a book about couples—many married, some living together who haven’t tied the knot, some straight and some gay—and what the word means to them, with text by Kashmir Hill.

“I believe that commitment applies to almost every aspect of life,” Mr. Hamburg explained last week in an email. “To be committed to what one is doing—in professions, business, in almost everything—one has to be committed to that to really be successful. And I may be right.”

Most of the couples featured in “Commitment” are longtime friends of the Hamburgs, including actor Jerry Stiller and his wife, Anne Meara, and comedienne Joy Behar and her husband, Steve Janowitz.

“This book proves that if anyone knows what commitment means, it’s Mort Hamburg,” Ms. Behar’s and Mr. Janowitz’s testimonial reads. “If you don’t believe us, just ask his wife, Joan.”

The list includes Southampton part-timers Arthur and Diane Abbey. When they met as teenagers nearly 60 years ago, commitment was far from their minds. They were just escaping the summer heat at Jones Beach.

In those days, all of the Long Island high schools claimed their squares of sand with blankets and picnic baskets. On Mr. Abbey’s trips to the Hempstead High section of the beach during the summer of 1954—where Diane Kirshbaum was a senior and he was an alumnus, and Hofstra University sophomore—he kept going back to her blanket.

He liked her peanut-butter-and jelly sandwiches, Ms. Abbey said, and she liked his Pontiac convertible.

“He had a car and he was a college student. It was a very big deal then for a kid going into her senior year of high school,” she said with a girlish laugh during a telephone interview last week. “We grew up together. I think we just go together. We’re a team. We work together. We like to be with each other. We’re with each other a lot. I can’t give you any secrets because I don’t have any.”

She laughed, and continued, “I think it’s a very give-and-take relationship. There’s ups and downs, but a commitment is that you care. You love each other. You’re with each other. You do things together. You have families together. That evolves into a commitment—not only to one another, but to a life together. And I think that’s within you and between you, really.”

When Peri Wolfman and Charlie Gold started dating, familial introductions weren’t necessary. Everyone had already met 15 years earlier during a celebration dinner for their parents—Mr. Gold’s mother had married Ms. Wolfman’s then-husband’s father.

“We were just very good friends for a long time,” Ms. Wolfman explained during a telephone interview last week. “I was living in San Francisco, he was living in New York. Then we happened to both be getting divorced at the same time.”

When she was in Manhattan on a business trip, they went out to lunch. And that was it, she said.

“We were just smitten with each other,” she said. “We hadn’t put that together earlier. It was really just a spontaneous thing.”

Though the couple and their four sons moved into an apartment together in 1980, marriage wouldn’t come until many years later. The first year was filled with fighting—not between Mr. Gold and Ms. Wolfman, but between their children as they sorted out the hierarchy.

Then came the mischief—“paper airplanes that the boys would set on fire and throw down from the terrace of their Gramercy Park apartment; frozen bottles of vodka in the freezer because too much of the vodka had been replaced with water; and a washer and dryer that kept breaking because the boys wanted to see what the spin cycle was like with one of them inside,” Ms. Wolfman wrote.

They eventually settled into a routine. But 16 years into their relationship, the “m” word began to loom, and with it, a sense of unease, she admitted. She was nervous to take the next step.

“We had such a good relationship, not married. We were a little afraid of jinxing it,” Ms. Wolfman said. “And also, in those days—it was 1980 when we got together—it was a little bit different that we weren’t married. It was a bit of fun.”

The dynamic duo decided to surprise their 1996 Labor Day houseguests with a wedding overlooking the fields at their summer home in Bridgehampton. They’ve since sold that home and moved to Southampton.

In retrospect, Ms. Wolfman said she still doesn’t know how they pulled it off. She hid the chuppah in the front yard, organized a clambake reception in the back and baked the cake herself as family and friends looked on.

“I’m making a white cake in my bathing suit and frosting it, and no one says to me, ‘Why are you making this cake?’” she said. “I guess they were scared of me. I was an ogre that day.”

The ceremony went off without a hitch, she said, and just the way she wanted it: simple and beautiful, with a bouquet of blue hydrangeas picked from her garden to carry down the aisle.

“I’ll tell you, marriage does change things—when you go to husband and wife, rather than ‘my partner,’” she said. “It does change things. You take the person more for granted, definitely. Commitment. And I think that’s a fabulous title for Mort’s book. I think commitment is exactly what the word means: you’re committed to someone. Just because something goes awry, you’re not going to jump ship. You’re going to figure it out and stick it out and work it out.”

Even though Mr. Hamburg’s book releases on the international day of love, these three couples don’t need Valentine’s Day to reaffirm their affections, they said. Decades of commitment do the talking.

“I’m just thinking, what day is Valentine’s Day?” Ms. Rosenthal mused over the telephone. “We’re not overtly into that kind of festivities after 50 years.”

Her husband yelled out in the background, evoking a giggle from Ms. Rosenthal.

“Charles says, at least he knew when it was,” she laughed. “We used to exchange gifts, but I don’t think we do that anymore. If I were to get an incredible box of chocolates, I’d be happy.”

“Commitment” by Mort I. Hamburg will be available on Thursday, February 14, online at Amazon.com and on bookshelves nationwide.

You May Also Like:

John Melillo Shares His Artistic Journey at Southampton Arts Center

John Melillo, Vietnam veteran and local artist, will be at the Southampton Arts Center on Saturday, November 9, at 2 p.m. to offer a presentation on his artistic journey and his progression of healing through art. Melillo, a contemporary realist painter, grew up on the East End. As a disabled Vietnam veteran he uses painting as a solace and healing mechanism from PTSD. “Art saved me,” said Melillo who paints two themes — the East End landscape and the “Lighter Side of Vietnam.” Through a compelling presentation of art and video, Melillo will take the audience through his personal history ... 1 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

A Matter of ‘Grit and Grain’ at Ashawagh Hall

Folioeast will present “Grit and Grain,” a group exhibition of work by eight artists, running ... 29 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Peter Dayton's 'Dark Garden' Is at Home at Guild Hall

Guild Hall in East Hampton is home to a long-term installation by artist Peter Dayton. ... 28 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Long Island Historic Sites, Including East End Museums, Win Awards for Excellence

Four Long Island historic sites received Awards for Excellence from the Greater Hudson Heritage Network (GHHN) for their innovative work engaging and educating visitors through the use of modern technology as well as by turning back the clock to the mid-1960s. The East Hampton Historical Society, the Oysterponds Historical Society in Orient, and the Oyster Bay Railroad Museum jointly accepted an award for their work on a series of free history-based augmented reality apps known as Digital Tapestry. The Montauk Historical Society won an award for its “Leisurama” exhibit recreating the interior of an iconic mid-century home, made possible by ... by Staff Writer

Innovation or Inundation? David Abel's New Documentary Dives Into the Issue of Development and Climate Change

It’s a fact of life that can no longer be ignored or denied. Sea level ... by Annette Hinkle

Joseph Vecsey's 'All Star Comedy' Is Back at Bay Street

Joseph Vecsey’s “All Star Comedy” show returns to Bay Street Theater on Saturday, November 9, ... 26 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

The Playwrights’ Theatre of East Hampton Presents a Cautionary Tale of History

The Playwrights’ Theatre of East Hampton at LTV Studios will present a concert staging of ... by Staff Writer

Ross Bleckner Monotype Benefits Guild Hall

Renowned American artist and East Hampton resident Ross Bleckner has created a series of monotypes ... 22 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Home for the Holidays With Truman Capote

Center Stage at Southampton Arts Center will present the Long Island premiere staged readings of Truman Capote’s holiday short stories collection — “The Thanksgiving Visitor,” “One Christmas” and “A Christmas Memory” on two consecutive November weekends. Performances of “The Thanksgiving Visitor” will be held on Friday, November 15, at 7 p.m., Saturday, November 16, at 2 and 7 p.m. and Sunday, November 17, at 2 p.m. Performances of “One Christmas” and “A Christmas Memory” will be held on Friday, November 29, at 2 p.m. (before the annual Southampton Village Christmas Parade), Saturday, November 30, at 2 and 7 p.m., and ... by Staff Writer

The Parrish Features Creativity From the Stars

The Parrish Art Museum will present “Collider,” a new public artwork by Rafael Lozano-Hemmer, as part of its annual façade installation series. Made up of hundreds of small LED spotlights that create a calm, rippling curtain of light along the museum’s exterior south wall, “Collider,” which debuted on October 14, is now visible from Montauk Highway and up close from the museum’s meadow. The piece will be on view through November 16, 2025, and the lights react in real-time to invisible cosmic radiation from outer space, originating from stars and black holes, detected by a custom-made muon detector installed at ... by Staff Writer