Making Beach Plum Jelly Is A Long-Standing Local Tradition, But Good Luck Getting Anyone To Reveal Where To Find The Plums - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1337488

Making Beach Plum Jelly Is A Long-Standing Local Tradition, But Good Luck Getting Anyone To Reveal Where To Find The Plums

icon 6 Photos

author on Dec 1, 2016

The elusive—and delicious—beach plum.

There is perhaps no East End edible more local than beach plum jelly. The recipe varies from family to family, with some held as closely as any other valuable heirloom. Cooking up the jelly is a fall tradition dating back many generations.

Gardener, floral designer and beach plum aficionado Elizabeth Yastrzemski recently shared her jelly-making skills with an enthusiastic group of students at the Southampton Historical Museum’s Rogers Mansion in Southampton Village.

One of those students, Diane Howe, was born and raised in Bridgehampton with a grandmother and great-grandmother who both turned out batches of the jelly every year.

“I wish I had thought about it when I was younger,” she said. “It’s an old-time thing, and it was something my grandmother and great-grandmother made, but I never thought to ask how they made it.”

Of course, making the jelly is one thing—finding the key ingredient is something else entirely. “I have an aunt who used to gather the beach plums,” Ms. Howe said. “I’m hoping she’ll pass on her secret location to me.”

Beach plums grow along the shore near ocean and bays, and are virtually unknown outside of Northeast beach communities like the Hamptons and Cape Cod. Like favorite fishing spots, their location is jealously guarded. “People keep it a secret, where they pick,” Ms. Yastrzemski said. “I certainly do. I go by paddleboard to pick mine, and I would never tell someone where I get them.”

Judy Johnson, a fan of Ms. Yastrzemski’s beach plum jelly, said she signed up for the class even though she’s made the jelly herself in the past from an old recipe passed along by a friend. “It’s a major effort, getting the beach plums, and all that … when I saw that each person in the class was going home with two jars of jelly, that was a big incentive.” As for her past plum foraging expeditions: “I’m not going to tell you where I got the plums.”

The prized shrubs, which can grow to a height of 6 feet, were once abundant along local beaches, but as development eats up more and more beachfront property, they get harder to find every year. Now, some fans say they go to Montauk to find them.

They can be cultivated, but the results are often disappointing. “It takes a really long time to grow them, and they don’t seem to grow as well in rich soil,” Ms. Yastrzemski said. “I also think that where they grow adds to the flavor of the fruit.”

Smaller than the common plums they’re related to, beach plums flower in the spring and the fruit comes ripe in the fall. Local lore says the crop is plentiful every other year. This was not a great year for the fruit, despite an abundance of spring blooms. Using a mix of slightly under-ripe and ripe plums helps ensure the jelly will set. The end product has a flavor all its own.

“It’s unique, sort of tart like currant, but different,” Ms. Johnson said. “And it’s such a beautiful, clear, deep red color. It’s a very pretty jelly.”

Harvesting the fruit in the wild is an important part of the ritual, according to Emily Halsey. At 93, she no longer forages for the fruit herself, but remembers, “It was so much fun to go and pick the berries on the beach. It’s a whole experience in itself, and such a fun thing to do. We would make a day of it.”

Ms. Halsey, who grew up in England, learned to make the jelly from her mother-in-law. These days, she still makes it, but relies on Ms. Yastrzemski to supply beach plum juice to start from.

“I haven’t made it yet,” she said shortly before Thanksgiving, “but I have to do it before Christmas. I give it away for Christmas presents. All my kids and grandkids like it; they look forward to having it each year.”

So far, none of her family members have shown an interest in making it themselves, but she is hoping to enlist her granddaughter to help cook this year’s jelly, and maybe pass along the tradition. “I hope at least one of my grandchildren will carry it on,” she said. “I’m afraid people won’t even know what beach plums are eventually; they won’t even bother with them.”

But at least for this holiday season, fans of the process and the product are keeping the tradition alive. For those without their own secret beach plum picking spot, Ms. Yastrzemski’s jelly is available for purchase at Herrick’s Hardware Store in Southampton or Holly Hill farm stand in Water Mill.

You May Also Like:

Springs Artist Fitzhugh Karol Debuts Outdoor Sculpture Show at Duck Creek

The Arts Center at Duck Creek will present “Fitzhugh Karol: On the Grounds,” a site-specific ... 8 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

La Goulue Sur Mer Arrives in Southampton, With a Dash of Chaos and a Side of Style

“Is it true?” said the anxious DM on my Instagram account. “Is La Goulue really ... by Steven Stolman

Art on a Line: Guild Hall’s Clothesline Sale Hangs Tough for 2025

Guild Hall’s beloved Clothesline Art Sale returns on Saturday, July 19, from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. The annual event, a Hamptons tradition since 1946, transforms the museum’s lawn into a sea of original artwork — hung on clotheslines — and offers visitors the chance to purchase local art at accessible prices. Jackson Pollock once sold a painting at the sale for $250, and past participants have included Lee Krasner, Alfonso Ossorio, Elaine and Willem de Kooning and other art-world icons. The event continues to offer a rare opportunity for the public to view and purchase work by East End ... by Staff Writer

The Climate-Friendly Fitness Routine

“Live simply so that others might simply live” — Mahatma Gandhi The first time I ... by Jenny Noble

Joy Behar Gets the Last Laugh in ‘My First Ex-Husband' at Bay Street Theater, July 14-19

Emmy Award-winning comedian and co-host of “The View,” Joy Behar stars in “My First Ex-Husband,” a bold, funny and heartfelt new play based on true stories from her life. The limited engagement runs July 14 through 19, at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor. With razor-sharp wit and no filters, “My First Ex-Husband” explores the messy, hilarious truths of love, sex and relationships. Adapted from Behar’s personal experiences, the show is both deeply personal and widely relatable. Behar will appear on stage on July 14, 18 and 19. Also appearing nightly, July 14 through 19, are Veanne Cox, a Tony-nominated ... by Staff Writer

Experience the Rhythms of Brazil With Nilson Matta’s Voyage Quartet

Grammy-nominated bassist Nilson Matta will lead his Brazilian Voyage Quartet at The Church on Friday, July 25, at 6 p.m. The concert is part of Hamptons JazzFest. The group features acclaimed guitarist Chico Pinheiro and offers a rich exploration of samba, bossa nova and modern Brazilian jazz. Matta, a founding member of the renowned Trio da Paz and longtime collaborator with Yo-Yo Ma on the Grammy-winning “Obrigado Brazil” project, is known for blending traditional Brazilian rhythms with contemporary jazz. His lyrical bass playing and deep rhythmic connection have earned him international acclaim. Guitarist Chico Pinheiro, recognized as a leading voice ... by Staff Writer

At the Galleries for July 10, 2025

Montauk The Depot Art Gallery, at the Montauk railroad station at the corner of Flamingo ... by Staff Writer

Round and About for July 10, 2025

Fireworks Shelter Island Fireworks The Shelter Island fireworks will be held on Saturday, July 12, ... by Staff Writer

Curtis Institute of Music Alumni and Faculty To Perform in East Hampton on July 22

Talented alumni and faculty from the world-renowned Curtis Institute of Music will tour the East Coast this summer, with a concert scheduled for Tuesday, July 22, at 7 p.m. at the First Presbyterian Church of East Hampton. The event is presented by Music for Montauk. The program features beloved melodies ranging from Gershwin’s “Porgy and Bess” to works by Brahms and de Falla. Performers include mezzo-soprano Katie Trigg, violinist Elissa Lee Koljonen, pianist Hanchien Lee, and Curtis Institute President and violist Roberto Díaz. The concert program includes: Manuel de Falla’s “Suite Populaire Espagnole,” performed by Díaz (viola) and Lee (piano); ... by Staff Writer

'Bonnie & Clyde' Cast and Crew Announced for Bay Street Musical

Bay Street Theater has unveiled the complete cast and creative teams for its pulse-pounding musical ... 7 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer