Gary Persan - 27 East

Gary Persan

icon 1 Photo

author on Nov 6, 2012

Gary Persan

Gary Persan, who was a highly regarded commercial fisherman in Montauk, died on October 19 in Melbourne, Florida, after injuring his head in a fall at home, his family said. He was 63.

Mr. Persan had long suffered from the effects of chronic Lyme disease, which in recent years left him disabled. According to a brother, Robert Persan of Sag Harbor, Mr. Persan was the first Long Islander to be diagnosed with the tick-borne condition by doctors at Stony Brook University Medical Center during the 1970s.

Born in Massapequa to Edgar Persan and Betty Sanders Persan, who both predeceased him, Mr. Persan was educated in local schools and began to visit Montauk, where his family had a summer home, in the 1960s.

“Gary started fishing in Montauk in the early ’70s,” Bob Persan said. “He started on sportfishing boats, fishing for sharks, before moving on to pin hooking. He was ‘high hook’ in the stripped bass commercial fishing and also well known in the commercial tuna industry, spending days off in the Canyons” on his boat “Stay Away.”

Faced with increasing competition and ever more restrictive regulations, Mr. Persan left Montauk with his wife, the former Mary Fagen, moving first to Key West, Florida, to fish the Tortugas and later settling in Melbourne Beach to fish the kingfish migrations.

“Gary loved fishing—and he was good at it,” Bob Persan said. “He also had a great sense of humor and was generous.”

Besides his wife and brother, Mr. Persan is survived by a son, Michael, of Melbourne, Florida, and another brother, Brian Persan of Montauk. He is also survived by five nieces and nephews, Karin Persan of Brooklyn, Ashley Persan of Salt Lake City, Ryan Persan of Montauk, Leah Persan-Boyle of East Hampton and John Persan of Montauk.

Mr. Persan was cremated. His family plans to hold a memorial service and spread his ashes in the rips off Montauk at a later date.

You May Also Like:

Charles Frederic ‘Charlie’ Corwith Jr. of Water Mill Dies October 31

Charles Frederic Corwith Jr. (Charlie) of Water Mill, NY passed peacefully on October 31, 2025. ... 4 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Frederic Dennis Philley, formerly of Montauk, Dies October 16

Frederic Dennis Philley, formerly of Montauk and East Springfield, died on October 16, with his ... 30 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Elizabeth Spitz, Formerly of East Hampton, Dies October 15

Elizabeth Spitz, affectionately known to her close friends and family as “Betty,” peacefully passed away ... 29 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Alice Tillotson of Sagaponack Dies October 23

Alice Tillotson of Sagaponack died on October 23 in Westhampton Beach. She was 74. Funeral arrangements will be private. Memorial donations may be made to East End Hospice or the Salvation Army. 28 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Anthony Lombardo, Formerly of East Hampton, Dies October 20

Anthony Lombardo, a retired designer and manufacturer of fine furniture and decorative wall paneling, died ... 27 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Dr. John J. Cossentino, Formerly of Montauk and Southampton, Dies October 5

Dr. John J. Cossentino, of St. Petersburg, Florida, and formerly of Ft, Myers, Florida, Brooklyn, ... 15 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Jan Page of North Haven Dies July 31

Jan Page of North Haven died on July 31, she was 86. In the last ... 6 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Patrick Michael Croke, Formerly of Southampton, Dies September 25

Patrick Michael Croke, 65, of South Salem, NY, passed away on Thursday, September 25th, 2025, ... 30 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Caroline Hackney of New York and Sag Harbor Dies September 12

Caroline Hackney, known to all as Ki, passed away peacefully, surrounded by family, after a ... by Staff Writer

Kathy Hinz of Sag Harbor Dies September 7

Kathy Hinz, 72, passed away peacefully on September 7, 2025, in her beloved Sag Harbor ... 22 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer