Objections To Montauk House Question Whether A Roof Is Flat Or Not - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1392465

Objections To Montauk House Question Whether A Roof Is Flat Or Not

icon 4 Photos
The view from the Stavola property of the new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk. Joe Stavola

The view from the Stavola property of the new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk. Joe Stavola

The view from the Stavola property of the new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk. Joe Stavola

The view from the Stavola property of the new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk. Joe Stavola

The new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk.

The new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk.

The new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk.

The new home built by Michael Gengos on Hudson Road in Montauk.

author27east on Mar 4, 2019

A Montauk homeowner has taken the East Hampton Town Building Department to task over its issuance of a building permit to a neighbor for what he describes as a third story on a house—that happens to be smack in the middle of his line of sight to the ocean.

The house built last year at 10 Hudson Road, in Hither Hills, is not unlike most other modern designs in the sloping neighborhoods where each house gazes out to the Atlantic over the top of the one downhill from it: It has a flat roof, which can double as a lofty deck space where owners and guests will be able to lounge with the ocean as a backdrop.

But in the center of its flat expanse, the house also has a 30-foot-wide, nearly 8-foot-tall, gabled structure with glass doors that face seaward. The owner, Michael Gengos, and his representatives say the structure—they are calling it an “attic”—is merely a shelter for the home’s HVAC units and the staircase the climbs to the roof from the interior of the house.

“It’s not habitable space,” Mr. Gengos’ attorney David Gilmartin said. “Habitable space has certain requirements with respect to size and this attic does not have the size required to come to the conclusion that this is habitable space. It’s storage for mechanicals and the roof deck.”

But a neighbor, Joseph Stavola, whose house sits just uphill of the Gengos property, says that the addition of the structure constitutes a third story of living space and violates town height limits. He says the space, while also acting as a shelter for mechanical equipment, is clearly meant to be used as living space, be it for additional seating under the roof or to host a rooftop bar area. He has asked the East Hampton Town Zoning Board of Appeals to throw out the building permit issued in 2017 for the house and consider whether the plans conform to town building codes.

“I don’t see how someone can build something 30 feet wide and 8 feet high and that’s not a third story,” Mr. Stavola said recently. “The building department isn’t saying anything to us. They are leaving it up to the ZBA. But why do I have to police the building department’s work? I’m not paid to do their job.”

Town code bars any third-floor living space and limits the height of flat-roofed homes to 25 feet, and gabled roofs to 30 feet.

Mr. Stavola says there is no discussion in the code about whether a flat-roofed home can have a gabled structure atop it also, or if that would mean the gabled roof height limit should then be applied.

But before the ZBA can get into whether or not the permit was issued improperly or not, it must consider whether Mr. Stavola’s objections were raised in time. State law allows just 60 days from the time that another person might “reasonably have been aware” of the issuance of a building permit, for objections to be raised.

Mr. Stavola says that the rooftop addition was constructed in late June of last year and that he hired an attorney and filed his objections in mid-August. Before the “attic” was actually built, he said, it’s true nature was not evident.

“Before that, there was no way to tell what it was,” he said. “It looked like it was a lean-to covering some equipment until the windows and doors went in.”

Mr. Gilmartin says that he would think Mr. Stavola should reasonably be expected to have become aware of the project’s details in November 2017 when the previous house on the property was demolished. But certainly the clock should have started ticking on the 60-day limit to raise an objection when Mr. Stavola’s father, Dan Stavola, visited the construction site in March of last year, according to Mr. Gilmartin.

“He had an obligation at that point to go and see the building permit and see if there was anything he would object to,” Mr. Gilmartin said. “The idea that the time starts when he says he noticed something that he thought was improper is just completely arbitrary.”

The ZBA is expected to again discuss Mr. Stavola’s objections to the Gengos house at its March 19 meeting.

You May Also Like:

Quail Ridge Residents Scramble After Apartments Are Purchased for Redevelopment | 27Speaks Podcast

The tenants of Quail Ridge — the two dozen studio and one-bedroom apartments spread over ... 3 Jul 2025 by 27Speaks

Water Mill Property Where Hal Buckner and Dorothy Lichtenstein Left Their Marks Is for Sale

A Water Mill property that hosts a former dairy barn turned artist’s studio and a ... 30 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Sundays on the Bay Hits the Market

Sundays on the Bay restaurant and marina on Dune Road in Hampton Bays has hit ... 29 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Hamptons Rental Market Remains Alive and Well

To paraphrase Mark Twain, reports of the demise of the Hamptons summer-rental market are greatly exaggerated. “Any hint that the Hamptons rental market is anything but robust is completely wrong,” said Corcoran associate broker Gary DePersia in East Hampton. An interesting dynamic is stirring in the Hamptons vacation-rental market. Although there has been an unprecedented rise in short-term rentals and the aftershocks of the COVID-19 pandemic linger, it has been a bumper crop year for Wall Street, interest rates have remained steady and a new breed of demanding customer is emerging. Despite it all, the Hamptons vacation-rental market remains as ... 19 Jun 2025 by Joseph Finora

Jon Vaccari Joins Noble Black & Partners at Douglas Elliman

Jon Vaccari, a longtime resident of Sag Harbor, has joined Noble Black & Partners at ... 18 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Appeals Court Sides With Landowner Over Southampton Village ZBA

Southampton Village has lost an appeal that sought to reinstate a Zoning Board of Appeals ... 12 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Last Parcel of Startop Ranch in Montauk Sells

The last plot of land at Startop Ranch in Montauk, 107 Startop Drive, has sold ... by Staff Writer

Hamptons Real Estate Roundtable, Memorial Day Weekend 2025 Edition

With Memorial Day weekend about to kick the Hamptons into high season, The Express News ... 22 May 2025 by Moderated by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Au-Delà Real Estate Vows To Go 'Beyond'

Au-Delà Real Estate, a new boutique real estate firm based in East Hampton, is now ... 20 May 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

AI Helps Rental Seekers Find Homes That Match Their Aesthetic Preferences

Consumers increasingly have an expectation of superior, more personalized service based on their own particular ... by Steven Loeb