Southampton Sports

Baymen Boys Soccer Eliminated From Postseason Contention After Frustrating Loss

icon 6 Photos
Hampton Bays junior midfielder Nico Carmona plays the ball to his feet with a Mt. Sinai player on him.

Hampton Bays junior midfielder Nico Carmona plays the ball to his feet with a Mt. Sinai player on him. DREW BUDD

Hampton Bays senior Francisco Funez pressures a Mt. Sinai player.

Hampton Bays senior Francisco Funez pressures a Mt. Sinai player.

Hampton Bays junior Justin Jimenez eludes a Mt. Sinai player.

Hampton Bays junior Justin Jimenez eludes a Mt. Sinai player. DREW BUDD

Hampton Bays junior John Pacheco gears up to boot the ball.

Hampton Bays junior John Pacheco gears up to boot the ball. DREW BUDD

Junior Bayman Juan Alape heads the ball.

Junior Bayman Juan Alape heads the ball. DREW BUDD

Junior Juan Salas heads the ball back out of the Baymen's defensive end.

Junior Juan Salas heads the ball back out of the Baymen's defensive end. DREW BUDD

Drew Budd on Mar 26, 2021

There are 80 minutes in a varsity high school soccer game and sometimes just a few of those minutes can control the outcome of the game. In the case of the Hampton Bays boys soccer team, it decided its postseason fate.

The Baymen controlled what their head coach Scott Garofola said was most likely 72 minutes of Thursday’s home game, but those eight minutes or so that they didn’t led to a pair of goals for Mount Sinai, which went on to win the game, 2-1, and dashing any hopes Hampton Bays had of returning to the postseason.

It was the fourth consecutive loss for the Baymen (1-4-1 League IV, 2-5-1 overall), who started the season with a 2-1-1 start, including a season-opening, non-league victory over cross-town rival Southampton. The loss also ends what had been a steady run of reaching the playoffs the past few seasons, including a county final appearance in 2018.

Section XI, the governing body of Suffolk County high school athletics, condensed the fall season into basically a month and a half due to the coronavirus pandemic. Because of the shortened season, the county had to use less leagues with more teams in each, creating, in most cases, extremely competitively league play. It also didn’t allow for teams to see each other twice, which when finishing the regular season with a .500 record or better qualifies a team for the playoffs, can help in that regard.

“There’s really no day off this year. You’ve got to come and play every day,” Garofola said. “There’s no day where you can bring your ‘B’ game and you’re going to win. We see that, even in times where you are dominating play. There are still a lot of dangerous guys out there — dangerous players, great strikers — that can really hit the ball and all you have to do is give them a couple of opportunities.

“Unfortunately, even with our play being high quality today, we made some mistakes and gave up those opportunities.”

George Franks scored both goals for the Mustangs. Just three minutes into the game, he found himself at the top of the box with the ball, turned and buried an unsavable shot top shelf past a diving Juan Cardona to make it a quick 1-0 game.

About 10 minutes later, Franks caught the Baymen defense napping a bit, getting behind both the defense and goalie to score on an empty net and make it 2-0.

From that point on though, Hampton Bays really controlled the tempo and possession of the game. With just under five minutes remaining in the first half, Hampton Bays senior Cris Vasquez sent a ball deep into the box that freshman Emmanuel Lopez — who was just substituted into the game — got his head on and was able to direct the ball passed Mt. Sinai goalie Tom Zariff to make it a 2-1 at halftime.

Although they controlled the game the rest of the way, the Baymen couldn’t capitalize on anything, and it was clear frustration was mounting. Justin Jimenez, a junior, made a nice move into the box with just minutes remaining in the game and booted a shot that appeared to go off a Babylon defender’s hand. The official didn’t see it, though, and therefore a potential game-tying penalty kick was not awarded.

“Honestly, it was a hard one to assess because it’s very frustrating and we really did a good job in our possession, in our style of play, in really playing the game,” Garofola said of the loss. “But the final third, the final ball and the final run wasn’t really there today, which I think was a big piece, and then also just making sure we were turned on at all moments to make sure we didn't give up a bad opportunity, and we did, and they capitalized on two of those.

“We took a lot of things from the training pitch yesterday, in terms of our movement as a unit, the possession during the game,” he added. “We absolutely dominated possession. I mean, we probably had the ball on our feet for a good 70 percent of the game. Our play was good in that regard, we dominated play, without a doubt. But, those down moments, you still have to stay on, you still have to stay focused, and a couple times we just didn't put together a full 80 minutes. We put together a good 72 minutes. That 72 minutes doesn't get you there and that was kind of the problem today.”

You May Also Like:

To Lob or Not To Lob? That Is the Question

Pickleball has many different shots depending on your court position, your opponent’s court position and ... 18 Nov 2025 by Vinny Mangano

Westhampton Beach Athletes Ready To Take Talents to Next Level

Thomas Machin has had the goal of playing baseball in college since he was 9 ... by Desirée Keegan

Rizzo Finishes 11th in the State To Earn All-State Honors at Cross Country Championships

Evelyn Rizzo capped her breakout cross country season with an 11th place finish at the ... by Drew Budd

Southampton's Hayden Gilmartin Finishes Cross Country Career at State Championship Meet

Hayden Gilmartin finished her high school cross country career at one of the last meets ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Brings Back Boys Volleyball at Junior High Level This Winter; District Also Sending Swimmers to East Hampton

Junior high boys within the Southampton School District should be preparing themselves to bump, set ... by Drew Budd

A Reprieve From Wind, Finally

Waterfowl season is upon us. Saturday will be the main season opener for most duck ... by Mike Wright

Early Momentum Fades as Bonac Football Drops County Semifinal to Sayville

Following his team’s 28-14 loss at Sayville in the Suffolk County Division III semifinal on ... by Drew Budd

Around the Post Pickleball Dinner at Villa Paul Is December 12

The second annual Around the Post Pickleball Dinner is set for Friday, December 12, at Villa Paul Restaurant in Hampton Bays at 7 p.m. The buffet dinner in the restaurant’s private dining room is $55 per person and includes the meal, tax and tip. Drinks are not included, but may be purchased separately. Those interested in attending should email Scott Green at scottgreen@optonline.net to confirm their spot. While open to anyone who appreciates the sport of pickleball, space is limited to 48 guests. 17 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Westhampton Girls Tennis Team Falls to Horace Greeley in State Semifinals

Ana Way said it was refreshing to see her Westhampton Beach girls tennis team reach ... 11 Nov 2025 by Desirée Keegan

Westhampton Boys Volleyball Proud of Showing Despite Eastport's Sweep in County Semifinal

Cameron Giordano is proud of the fact that for the second straight season with a ... by Desirée Keegan