Cupsogue And Smith Point Beaches Reopen To Swimmers On Holiday Following Sunday Closure After Shark Attack In Shirley - 27 East

Cupsogue And Smith Point Beaches Reopen To Swimmers On Holiday Following Sunday Closure After Shark Attack In Shirley

Kitty Merrill on Jul 3, 2022

A shark attack, injuring a lifeguard, in the waters off Smith Point County Park in Shirley led to the closure of both that beach and Cupsogue County Park in Westhampton to swimming on Sunday, July 3.

By Monday morning, they had reopened the waters for the holiday, with extensive monitoring underway.

Suffolk County Legislator Bridget Fleming reported on Monday that county lifeguards — “the best in the country” — had normal “dangerous marine life” protocols in place. They include watching the waters on personal watercraft, paddleboards, surfboards and kayaks, plus observation from land. Because someone had been bitten, Suffolk County’s Fire Rescue and Emergency Services also participated in monitoring, using drones.

Suffolk County Executive Steve Bellone, appearing at a press conference at Smith Point on Sunday afternoon, said the lifeguard who was attacked and bitten was in good spirits and doing well.

Bellone said the lifeguard, Zack Gallo, was bitten in the chest and hand, the bites requiring stitches. Gallo has been a lifeguard with the county for 10 years.

Bellone said there had never been an attack at Smith Point before. “This is the first time we are aware of any beachgoer bitten by a shark,” he said.

The incident occurred at around 10:15 Sunday morning as the lifeguards were engaged in a training exercise. Gallo was playing the role of a victim when the interaction with the shark occurred.

It was a serendipitous moment, the county executive noted. If one is going to have an encounter with a shark, it was fortuitous that help was so nearby during the exercise when Gallo, ironically, actually became a victim.

Bleeding “significantly,” Gallo was walked out of the water, at first unaware of what caused his injuries. He was taken to the beach station, where an EMT bandaged him, Bellone said, then taken to Southside Hospital in Bay Shore.

As a result, the beaches at both Smith Point and Cupsogue were closed to swimming for the remainder of Sunday. There was an additional sighting of a shark after the incident occurred, the county executive reported. It appeared the animal was about 4 to 5 feet long.

After the incident, drones and lifeguards using personal watercraft were deployed to monitor the water. They continued the monitoring on July 4, then decided to open the waters back up to swimmers.

“We expect the beach will be open for swimming tomorrow — if a sighting occurs, that may change,” Bellone said on Sunday.

More than two dozen species of sharks swim the waters off Long Island. According to the State Department of Environmental Conservation, species found in coastal areas include the common thresher, dusky, sand tiger, sandbar, smooth hammerhead, white shark, and dogfish. Of those, the hammerhead and white shark are deemed dangerous, with hammerhead interactions with humans listed as the most likely.

Adult white sharks, which can reach over 18 feet in length, are considered dangerous, also, due to their size, power, and feeding behaviors. They are also called “great white sharks.”

Several years ago, researchers dubbed the waters off Montauk a “nursery” for baby white sharks after they found and tagged some nine white shark pups.

Not to worry, though: Last year, there was a total of 73 confirmed unprovoked shark attacks worldwide, according to Florida Museum’s International Shark Attack File. A person is more likely to be bitten by a dog, a raccoon — or another human, according to their statistics.

The odds of being attacked and killed by a shark are 1 in 3,748,067 (0.000026 percent). A person is more likely to be struck by lighting, or, as was widely reported in 2020, die while taking a selfie.

You May Also Like:

Body Found in East Hampton Woods Identified as Missing Riverside Man

The body of a Riverside man reported missing in November last year was found in a wooded area off Route 114 in East Hampton on Monday, January 6. According to Southampton Town Police, a hunter in the woods located the body, and East Hampton Town Police and detectives as well as Suffolk County homicide detectives responded. The Suffolk County medical examiner’s office was contacted and removed the body for further investigation. The deceased was identified as Luis Vargas-Arias, 56. He had been reported missing to Southampton Town Police. According to the department’s November 3, 2024, bulletin, Vargas-Arias was last seen ... 6 Jan 2025 by Christopher Walsh

Protect Crabs

As reported in The Press, the New York State Legislature recently considered a proposal to increase the protection of Atlantic horseshoe crabs [“Governor ‘Drops the Axe’ on Horseshoe Crabs, Vetos Bill That Would Have Ended Commercial Harvest,” 27east.com, December 18]. Assemblyman Fred Thiele voted against the legislation, citing their value as bait in commercial fisheries. Horseshoe crabs are also caught and drained of up to one-third of their blue blood and then released back to the sea alive. There are cells in their blood, which, like white cells in human blood, can recognize bacteria and other toxins. One use of ... by Staff Writer

Usurped Land

Kudos to Michael Iasilli and Tommy John Schiavoni, who now serve on the Southampton Town Council and the New York State Assembly, respectively, for voting against suing the Shinnecock Nation for building a gas station on their own territory [“Southampton Town Will Sue Shinnecock Nation To Halt Hampton Bays Gas Station Development; Tribe Vows Defiance,” 27east.com, December 19]. In recent Letters to the Editor, people lamented the tearing down of trees and the harmful effects the construction will have on animals who live in these woods. We wonder why we do not hear the same outcry from people when trees ... by Staff Writer

Flag Rescue

The Water Mill Village Improvement Association would like to thank the Southampton Fire Department, along with Chief Emmanuel Escobar, Kenneth Lockard and Peter Feeney, as well as David Raynor Landscaping and his associates. The crews showed up at the request of the Water Mill Village Improvement Association after the flag on the Water Mill Village Green became stuck at the top of the 100- foot flagpole. The crew from Raynor Landscaping laid protective wood down on the green to protect it from the weight of the massive fire truck. Once the truck was in place, it took the firefighters no ... by Staff Writer

Signs of Love?

Near the end of Towd Road on the right was a rock with the saying “Do What You Love” painted in white. I smiled every time I saw it, and I took my grandchildren to share it with them. I’m pretty sure that many people enjoyed it as much as I did and found it inspirational, especially for young people. But now it’s gone — because the town has covered it with a plaque (something about land preservation). Besides covering the saying, they chose a poor spot on a rock where it doesn’t sit well in an area that most ... by Staff Writer

Everyday Hypocrisy

It does not matter where we get the definition of the hypocrite from, and it does not matter how many of them are out there. If you pretend that you are a different person than you are, you are a hypocrite. Some of us may object to such a description of ourselves, and we might be upset to be called this name, but the best way to find out if we are one of them is to look in the mirror. Some of us may say: No, it is not true — it is not me, the mirror is lying. ... by Staff Writer

Seventh Annual Messiah Sing on Shelter Island This Sunday

The Shelter Island Community Chorus will host its seventh annual Handel’s Messiah Sing, on Sunday, January 12, at 3 p.m. at the Shelter Island Presbyterian Church, 32 N. Ferry Road (Route 114), Shelter Island. The annual Messiah Sing honors the late Jack Monaghan, who founded the tradition, held each January on the first Sunday after Epiphany. The seventh annual Messiah Sing will include 11 choruses and a number of solos, led by Suzanne Nicoletti, and accompanied by Paolo Bertolani. Choristers are encouraged to bring their own scores, Schirmer Edition preferred; a limited number of scores will be available. East End ... by Staff Writer

Choral Society Opens Auditions for Next Concert

The Choral Society of the Hamptons will hold auditions on Monday, January 13, for all singing parts (soprano, alto, tenor, bass) for singers interested in joining the group prior to the Choral Society’s next concert on Sunday, March 30, at the First Presbyterian Church of East Hampton. The Choral Society rehearses at the same church and the auditions will take place there as well. Rehearsals begin the following Monday, January 20. Singers accepted into the chorus are welcome to attend this first rehearsal before committing to the chorus. Generally, there are weekly rehearsals on Monday evenings and occasional weekend commitments ... by Staff Writer

Race to Extremes

In Ed Surgan’s recent letter [“Let It Play Out,” Letters, December 26], he disagreed with me due to “primarily … faceless, anonymous sources.” The reality of D.C., statehouses and sometimes even local government is the use of anonymous sources when gathering information for a story. Retribution has become a key tool for many in power. Donald Trump, in fact, openly threatens the use of retribution quite often and did use it to punish perceived enemies during his first term. Whistleblower protection laws were enacted because of such threats and actions from people in power. What Mr. Surgan doesn’t acknowledge in ... by Staff Writer

VIEWPOINT: The Day I Almost Killed Jimmy Carter

Back when Jimmy Carter was president, politics didn’t even have a back seat in my life. It was just after college, and it was the dawn of my independence. My plan was to work hard, have fun, pay New York City rent and never have to lean on my parents again. My only memory of Jimmy Carter’s presidency was that interest rates went up so high that paying off credit cards cut into my bar tab. Worse, soon after Carter left office, Congress passed a bill that eliminated the tax deduction on the interest on credit cards. The payments must ... by By Donathan Salkaln