DEC Takes Hands Off Approach To Sand Land Enforcement - 27 East

DEC Takes Hands Off Approach To Sand Land Enforcement

icon 1 Photo
The Sand Land sand mine and recycling center in Noyac.

The Sand Land sand mine and recycling center in Noyac.

authorStephen J. Kotz on Nov 3, 2021

The Sand Land sand mine in Noyac has been buffeted by two Appellate Division court decisions since May, which declared the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation acted illegally when it issued a new mining permit for the operation in 2019. And last month, New York State Attorney General Letitia James announced that her office would no longer defend the DEC in the matter.

So why then, nearly six months after a judicial panel, by a 4-1 vote, ruled the permit was not valid, has the DEC not enforced the court’s ruling and shut the operation down?

At least part of the reason seems to be that Sand Land itself is now asking the state’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, to hear the case.

In a terse, two-sentence response to a recent inquiry about the matter, the DEC stated that it would not comment until the Court of Appeals rules on Sand Land’s request because “until that court rules on the motion, the matter is subject to potential litigation.”

Still, some onlookers ask why the DEC, which would surely ticket a fisherman who landed a short striped bass or fine a home builder whose deck was too close to a wetland, would be so accommodating to a mine that, for now at least, has no legal right to remain in operation.

“At the moment, they have no permit and they should not be mining,” said State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr., who has been a leader in an effort to close the mine down. “The fact that the DEC would ignore that is inexplicable, but that’s where we are.”

Although the state, through the DEC, generally has jurisdiction over mining, that is not always the case on Long Island, where the DEC is not allowed to approve a mining permit if the town where it is located has a local law on the books outlawing the practice, which Southampton Town does have.

Sand Land, which is owned by Wainscott Sand and Gravel, was in operation before the town adopted its zoning code, but over the decades, the operation expanded to include the processing of vegetative waste and construction debris. As the area around the mine became developed, the town and neighbors have tried to rein in the operation. A decade ago, the town Zoning Board of Appeals ruled that Sand Land could continue to mine, but had to shut down most of its ancillary operations.

Later, citing concern about groundwater pollution — the mine is in a groundwater protection district — the town began to fight the renewal of the mining permit. That effort took on new urgency in 2018 when water testing conducted by the Suffolk County Department of Health Services showed contamination by heavy metals and other pollutants of test wells at the Sand Land site, although Sand Land has disputed those findings.

Bob DeLuca, the president of the environmental organization The Group for the East End, has his own theory as to why the DEC will not close the mine.

“State mining law is basically schizophrenic,” he said. “The DEC is supposed to both promote and regulate mining. That’s a bad idea.”

Plus, he said, there is a disconnect between Long Island, the only part of the state to obtain its water solely from an aquifer, and the rest of the state, where sand mining is more acceptable.

“The appellate court has said twice the permit is null and void, and the state AG has essentially fired its client,” DeLuca said. “The DEC seems to believe they have permission to keep the mine open and they are going to do whatever is necessary.”

DeLuca said it was unnerving that the DEC would essentially ignore a court ruling. “It’s worrisome when these agencies go rogue,” he said. “Where do we go from here?” He added that it might be necessary for Governor Kathy Hochul to order the DEC to get in line and enforce the court ruling.

DeLuca said he saw reticence on the part of the town to confront the DEC. “There seems to be this kind of hope that the DEC will come to its senses and realize this permit is invalid and continued mining is beyond any limit of approval.”

Southampton Town attorney James Burke said it is frustrating that the DEC has refused to act and said the Town Board is exploring what other options it has. In the meantime, he said the town continues to issue summonses to Sand Land for violations, which are handled in town Justice Court.

“In general, I think they look at these complaints as NIMBYism,” Burke said of the DEC. “They don’t think that mining itself is deleterious. They don’t think the act of mining itself is injurious to the environment.”

David Arnsten, an attorney with the Nesconset law firm Volz & Vigliotta, which has represented the town in the Sand Land case in state court, said the law is “murky” when it comes to whether the state or Long Island towns like Southampton have more authority to regulate mines.

For now, he said, he would continue to discuss options with the Town Board and wait to see whether the Court of Appeals agrees to hear Sand Land’s case. If the court takes the case, the matter could drag on for months or even years. Asked if he thought Sand Land would be forced to close down if the Court of Appeals ruled against it in the coming weeks, he responded “one would think so.”

You May Also Like:

John Avlon and Nick LaLota on the Environment | 1st District Matters

As we face ever more severe weather, Long Island is a frontline region in navigating ... 31 Oct 2024 by The Express News Group & WLIW-FM

Rogers Memorial Library Earns Prestigious Sustainability Designation

The Rogers Memorial Library recently earned a prestigious distinction, receiving designation from the Sustainable Libraries ... 30 Oct 2024 by Cailin Riley

EPA Says It Wants To Observe Gas Station Construction, While Residents Prepare Legal Challenge

The Federal Environmental Protection Agency said this week that the Shinnecock Nation has applied for ... by Michael Wright

Beach Nourishment Projects Will Get Underway December 1

An ocean-going dredging crew will begin work on the broadening of six miles of ocean ... 25 Oct 2024 by Michael Wright

Federal EPA Says It Has 'Authority' Over Shinnecock Gas Station Project in Hampton Bays

The federal Environmental Protection Agency has told the Town of Southampton that it is acting ... 23 Oct 2024 by Michael Wright

Sixth Year of Die-Offs Hit Bay Scallops; Genetic Diversity Could Be Factor

The biologists doing surveys of local bay bottoms ahead of the annual bay scallop harvest ... by Michael Wright

Spring Farm Near Sag Harbor To Remain Hunting Preserve; Southampton Town in Talks To Limit Use

Spring Farm, a popular hunting preserve in the woods south of Sag Harbor that was ... by Stephen J. Kotz

No Exceptions for Gas-Powered Leafblower Ban in Southampton Village, Mayor Says

Southampton Village Mayor Bill Manger made it clear at the Southampton Village Board meeting on ... 22 Oct 2024 by Cailin Riley

Farrell Remake of Eastport Trailer Park Will Be '1,000 Percent Better' Despite Early Concerns, Attorney Says

Residents of Eastport voiced concerns to the Southampton Town Planning Board last week that the remaking of the former Leier’s Mobile Home Park by Bridgehampton developer Joe Farrell would bring undue environmental and congestion problems to the tiny hamlet of just over 2,000 residents. With the applications to the Planning Board for the new layout of the park in their earliest stage, even as some building permits have already been issued and the construction of some of the concrete pads that will hold the so-called “manufactured homes” is underway, residents spoke mostly of fears about the redevelopment not being adequately ... 16 Oct 2024 by Michael Wright

Friends Don't Let Friends Vote for Trump

“Knocking on doors is the only foolproof plan I’ve ever come up with for curing ... 10 Oct 2024 by Jenny Noble