Fentanyl Smuggling Ring Upended at Riverside County Jail Facility

icon 3 Photos
A fentanyl smuggling plot at the Riverside jail facility included drug-laced legal papers. TOM GOGOLA

A fentanyl smuggling plot at the Riverside jail facility included drug-laced legal papers. TOM GOGOLA

Suffolk County DA Ray Tierney and Sheriff Errol Toulon spelled out a plot to smuggle fentanyl into the Riverside jail facility. TOM GOGOLA

Suffolk County DA Ray Tierney and Sheriff Errol Toulon spelled out a plot to smuggle fentanyl into the Riverside jail facility. TOM GOGOLA

Suffolk County Sheriff Errol Toulon highlighted the dangers to corrections staff when dealing with the fentanyl scourge at the Riverside jail. TOM GOGOLA

Suffolk County Sheriff Errol Toulon highlighted the dangers to corrections staff when dealing with the fentanyl scourge at the Riverside jail. TOM GOGOLA

Tom Gogola on Nov 21, 2023

Five people were indicted last week for attempting to smuggle fentanyl into the Suffolk County Correctional Facility, soaking the drug into paper and then smuggling it in via unsuspecting lawyers as legal documents.

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney and Sheriff Errol Toulon were on hand at the Arthur Cromarty Court Complex in Riverside on November 16 to announce the indictments.

“Here we go again,” said Tierney to a room crowded with reporters and law enforcement officials as he spelled out a plot whereby the deadly drug was sprayed onto legal papers and then given to a defense attorney to deliver to the jail, unaware of the plot.

The plan, said Tierney, was for the papers to be cut up into smaller credit-card size pieces by the inmates and sold in the jail.

The plot was upended before the drugs were delivered to their intended recipient, said Tierney, who described the attempt as the “latest iteration” of a fentanyl crisis on Long Island that has left 399 overdose deaths in its wake. The problem is “getting worse,” he said, calling on state and county leaders to step up with legislation to address the crisis.

The attempted smuggling wasn’t the first time fentanyl had been brought into the jail, but the utilization of seemingly legitimate legal papers to deliver the drug represented one of the “more audacious attempts,” said Toulon, who noted that the fentanyl is 20 times more valuable in jail than on the street.

“If these criminals were successful in their attempt to smuggle more than $20,000 of deadly fentanyl into the jail, there is no doubt that tragedy would have followed,” Toulon noted in a follow-up press release announcing the multiple indictments.

Here’s how the plot unfolded, according to Tierney:

Back in August, corrections officials at the Riverside jail were tipped off that Jyzir Hamilton, 35, an inmate in the jail, was planning to have his girlfriend, Janiah Williams, 24, deliver fentanyl-laced papers to him through his defense attorney, “who allegedly had no knowledge of the plan,” according to the press release.

Hamilton then made a call to Alyssa Brienza, 30, and asked her about obtaining fentanyl. She, in turn, is alleged to have contacted Arnold Foster, 33, who is serving time at the Green Haven Correctional Facility upstate following his conviction for dealing drugs. Foster is alleged to have “set the price for the fentanyl to be sold to Hamilton,” setting in motion the attempted smuggling gambit.

Brienza is alleged to have delivered four blank pieces of paper to Williams that were then sprayed with “a liquid laced with fentanyl” that also contained acetone. Williams then told Brienza to contact an attorney who was representing Eric Freeman, 48, who told his attorney that someone would be delivering legal papers to him and asked that he pass along those documents, which would be delivered by Williams to Hamilton at the jail, via the attorney.

On August 23, Williams contacted the attorney and said she was on her way to the jail. She was arrested as she entered the Cromarty Building, where county sheriff officers “allegedly found a manila enveloped containing four pages with legal terms printed on them” in her possession.

Indictments followed in November for the five defendants, all of whom hail from Long Island.

Hamilton was charged with four felonies and a misdemeanor; Brienza was indicted on six felony counts and two misdemeanors; Williams was indicted on five felony charges; Freeman was indicted on one felony count; and Foster was also charged with a single felony. The charges include conspiracy, promoting prison contraband, attempted sale of a controlled substance and others.

Toulon and Tierney encouraged vigilance among attorneys in light of the alleged smuggling plot and seemingly relentless attempts to distribute fentanyl in the jail.

Toulon said the jail was “getting mail from ‘makeshift’ law firms that all had to be analyzed, creating an ongoing safety hazard for jail officials who may come into contact with the lethal lab-created drug. There were “already fentanyl-laced papers” coming into the jail before this brazen plot was upended, the sheriff said, noting the difficulty in safely screening the mail without causing harm to staffers or canine units that might typically be deployed to sniff out contraband.

You May Also Like:

School News, November 20, Southampton Town

Bridgehampton School Honors Local Heroes at Annual Veterans Day Ceremony On November 10, Bridgehampton School ... 18 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

To Lob or Not To Lob? That Is the Question

Pickleball has many different shots depending on your court position, your opponent’s court position and ... by Vinny Mangano

Westhampton Beach Athletes Ready To Take Talents to Next Level

Thomas Machin has had the goal of playing baseball in college since he was 9 ... by Desirée Keegan

Rizzo Finishes 11th in the State To Earn All-State Honors at Cross Country Championships

Evelyn Rizzo capped her breakout cross country season with an 11th place finish at the ... by Drew Budd

Southampton's Hayden Gilmartin Finishes Cross Country Career at State Championship Meet

Hayden Gilmartin finished her high school cross country career at one of the last meets ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Brings Back Boys Volleyball at Junior High Level This Winter; District Also Sending Swimmers to East Hampton

Junior high boys within the Southampton School District should be preparing themselves to bump, set ... by Drew Budd

A Reprieve From Wind, Finally

Waterfowl season is upon us. Saturday will be the main season opener for most duck ... by Mike Wright

Patricia C. Farrell of Sag Harbor Dies November 17

Patricia C. Farrell of Sag Harbor died on November 17 on Quioque. She was 92. A visitation will take place on Friday, November 21, from 3-7 p.m. at the Brockett Funeral Home in Southampton. A funeral Mass will be celebrated on Saturday, November 22, at 10 a.m. at St. Andrew’s Catholic Church in Sag Harbor. Memorial donations to East End Hospice (eeh.org) and Sag Harbor Food Pantry (sagharborfoodpantry.org). A complete obituary will appear in a future edition of The Press. by Staff Writer

Early Momentum Fades as Bonac Football Drops County Semifinal to Sayville

Following his team’s 28-14 loss at Sayville in the Suffolk County Division III semifinal on ... by Drew Budd

Great Place To Be

I read with deep attention to detail the almost full-page story on the lack of parking during the busy summer months in Westhampton Beach [“Westhampton Beach Village Board Exploring Paid Parking Options,” 27east.com, November 10]. I did note, happily, that Mayor Ralph Urban hedged his bets a number of times in the article as to whether or not paid parking for Main Street spots, or spots in the lot behind the shops on the south side of Main Street, was really a solution. Mr. Mayor, it’s not. (The silliest idea floated was to consider the East Hampton plan, which is ... by Staff Writer