Former Southampton resident Mary McBurney Gaynor dies at 90

icon 1 Photo

author on Nov 19, 2009

Former Southamp­ton resident Mary McBurney Gaynor of Essex, Connecticut, died on November 10 at her home. She was 90.

Born in Boston on October 19, 1919, she was the daughter of Jesse Holladay Philbin and Elizabeth Parker Philbin. A lifelong lover of the seacoast, marshes, beaches, and water birds, she spent her childhood in Cedarhurst. She graduated from Chatham Hall School in Virginia, where, according to family members, she claimed her most interesting pursuit by far was riding horses around the countryside.

In 1938, she entered the Boston Museum School. While both her grandmother and mother had been watercolorists, she soon discovered a passion for life drawing and figurative sculpture. Her studies were interrupted when World War II broke out: She married Watson Bradley Dickerman, who enlisted in the U.S. Navy, and she became a volunteer for the Red Cross in Washington, D.C.

After the war, the couple settled in New York City and she resumed her art studies at Columbia University, balancing this endeavor with the numerous social requirements of her husband’s career in banking, and the management of a household of four young children who had two doting, occasionally opinionated, single grandmothers in very close proximity.

At her insistence, the family moved out to Glen Cove in 1952. There she became a trustee at the Greenvale School and an active volunteer at a community settlement house in Glen Cove. Her love of bird-watching grew and she was finally able to indulge her love for animals, owning goats, dogs, and a horse. She also enjoyed a wealth of opportunities to participate in sports. Survivors recalled that she always told her children that if they could play golf and tennis and bridge and could ride and shoot and type, they could get along anywhere.

After Mr. Dickerman’s death in 1955, she married Doctor William C. T. Gaynor in 1957 and moved to Southampton. The following year Dr. Gaynor, who had five children, and Mrs. Gaynor, had a daughter together, for a total of 10 children in their family.

In Southampton, Mrs. Gaynor started a volunteer service at Southampton Hospital, where Dr. Gaynor served as chief of surgery. She did not find time to get back to her art until he retired in 1982 and they began a new life in Montego Bay, Jamaica.

Dr. Gaynor continued to practice medicine in Jamaica, and Mrs. Gaynor cultivated the skills as a hostess and resourceful entertainer that she would continue to draw on for the rest of her life. Their cottages in Jamaica also provided an exotic haven for visiting grandchildren. Among the couple’s many interesting Jamaican friends was a rug artist who taught Mrs. Gaynor the bargello stitch. Over the next 25 years, she designed and made at least 30 original rugs. Although many were sold, many remain in the family.

In 1989 Mr. and Mrs. Gaynor moved to Boca Grand, Florida where they lived until Mr. Gaynor’s death in 1999. Mrs. Gaynor then moved to Essex, Connecticut.

Described by survivors as slim and stylish, in boys’ camouflage jeans, vivid cashmere sweaters and snappy shoes, even in her ninth decade she was admired for her fine appearance, for her extraordinary generosity to people and causes she cared about, and for her straight talk.

She is survived by four daughters, Mary McBurney Swann of Maryland, Laine Gifford and Holly Dickerman, both of Massachusetts, and Katherine Marine of Arizona; 10 grandchildren; 11 great-grandchildren; a nephew; and several grand- and great-grandnieces and nephews.

She is also survived by three stepsons and many step-grandchildren and step-great-granchildren. Her only son, Watson Bradley Dickerman Jr., predeceased her.

A memorial service will be held on Monday, November 23, at 11 a.m., at Saint John’s Episcopal Church, Main Street, Essex, Connecticut. In lieu of flowers, memorial donations to Audubon Connecticut, 613 Riverdille Road, Greenwich, CT 06831 would be appreciated by the family.

You May Also Like:

John Philip Moloney of New York City and Southampton Dies November 18

John Philip Moloney of New York City and Southampton died at home in Southampton on ... 5 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Town Will Move To Ban Docks on Peconic Bay Shoreline

Southampton Town lawmakers threw their support behind a proposal to prohibit the construction of private ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Town Police Announce 2026 Civilian Academy

The Southampton Town Police Department will launch its 2026 Civilian Police Academy on January 15, ... by Staff Writer

Westhampton Beach Appoints New Assistant High School Principal

The Westhampton Beach School District has appointed Alyssa Tracey as the new assistant principal of ... by Staff Writer

A Surprise Every Morning: Sunrises Are Southampton Photographer's Specialty, and He Shares Them Daily on Instagram

Every day he’s in Southampton, Eric Nastri does the same exact thing. And yet, he ... 4 Dec 2025 by Cailin Riley

Southampton Turns Back to Outside Help To Stay Ahead of Building Application Deluge

Southampton Town has renewed a contract with a freelance building plans examiner to keep up ... by Michael Wright

Ground Broken for Westhampton Community Center; Long-Awaited Resource Could Open in 2026

Southampton Town officials held a ceremonial groundbreaking on the long-awaited Westhampton Community Center project next ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of December 4

SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — Matthew Kopoulos, 34, of East Hampton was arrested by Village Police on December 2 and charged with petit larceny and unlawfully fleeing an officer, both misdemeanors, stemming from a September 25 incident in which police say Kopoulos stole items from the 7-Eleven on North Sea Road and then fled the scene on an e-bike. When a Village Police officer attempted to stop him he sped away and drove onto the Shinnecock Territory. A village officer recognized Kopoulos walking on the side of Tuckahoe Road this week and placed him under arrest. He was arraigned in Village Justice ... by Staff Writer

Love in Action

On behalf of the Hamptons United Methodist Church, I would like to extend our heartfelt thanks to the generous donors and dedicated volunteers who made this year’s free community Thanksgiving dinner a remarkable success. Because of your kindness, we were able to serve nearly 500 of our neighbors — families, seniors, workers and individuals from all walks of life — by providing a holiday meal for their table. For the sixth year in a row, we are also deeply indebted to our fearless leader, Denise Smith-Meacham. To our volunteers: You peeled and chopped and cooked, packaged and delivered meals, washed ... by Staff Writer

A Day of Quiet

November 27, Thursday, Thanksgiving Day. Morning: I hear the screech owl, the great-horned owl, the Cooper’s hawk, Carolina wren, white-throated sparrow, chirps of the cardinal, red-breasted nuthatch, the cooo of the mourning dove; songs of rooster, flicker, dark-eyed junco. Titmouse, blue jay. Wind, barely a breeze, whispers haaaaaaaa in wind language, lovingly. Tranquility. Peace. I’m alive — ping of chill in the air, my skin zings. This sacred silence is why I moved here 40 years ago. But it’s completely gone now. And why? Was our designation of “green community” just a photo-op? A lie? Words co-opted like the phrase ... by Staff Writer