Former Southampton Village Mayor Douglas Murtha Dies June 8 - 27 East

Former Southampton Village Mayor Douglas Murtha Dies June 8

icon 2 Photos

authorGreg Wehner on Jun 9, 2016

The first time Dennis Farrell met Douglas Warren Murtha, who would eventually become his brother-in-law, he was impressed.

“I met him when I was in my mid 20s,” Mr. Farrell said. “How can you not like a guy who owns a lot of restaurants and clubs?”

Over the course of his life, not only was Mr. Murtha a three-term mayor of Southampton Village, he was also the owner of several local establishments, among them the Driver’s Seat in Southampton Village and the Chart Inn in Hampton Bays.

“He knew so many people in his travels,” Mr. Farrell said. “He could be in Florida, Manhattan or around the East End, and would run into people he knew. They always had kind words and memories.”

Mr. Murtha, who was 74, died on June 8 at Broadlawn Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Amityville. A funeral Mass was held on Monday morning at the Basilica of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary in Southampton.

Mr. Murtha was born in Brooklyn on March 4, 1942, to John and Anne Bauer Murtha. The family eventually moved to Seaford, where he and his three brothers, Jack, Bob and Gary, grew up.

As a young man, Mr. Murtha was an athlete who participated in wrestling and football. At Hofstra University, he was honored as an all-time letterman for his performance on the football team, playing as a linebacker and a running back in 1962 and 1963.

After graduating from Hofstra, he went on to become a teacher and the athletic director at the Lawrence Woodmere Academy in Woodmere.

Mr. Murtha would tend bar on the South Fork in the summers, and he moved east in the 1970s to open the Cruiser Club in Hampton Bays. Following the success of that nightclub, he opened the Chart Inn on the canal in Hampton Bays, which became a popular dining spot.

“Doug was wonderful, warm, inclusive and had a great sense of humor,” Mr. Farrell said.

While working in the Hamptons, Mr. Murtha met Susan Farrell, who was doing the same thing. They were married in 1976 at Saint Agnes Cathedral in Rockville Centre and raised two sons, Douglas and Robert, in Southampton. Doug Murtha Jr., 37, lives in Texas, and Robert Murtha, 27, lives in Georgia.

Beginning in the 1970s, Mr. Murtha and a partner, John Barnhill, owned the Driver’s Seat in Southampton Village, which was a fixture on Jobs Lane for more than 40 years, before selling it in 2005 to Irma Herzog.

Mr. Murtha was first elected mayor of the Village of Southampton in 1993. He served three two-year terms, and he was known for helping to provide access to village beaches as well as access for handicapped and physically challenged residents and guests in the business district.

“I believe Doug was instrumental in negotiating the land for what is now the Rogers Memorial Library, as well as the land for what is the Police Justice Center,” Mr. Farrell said. “Probably the biggest of his accomplishments was the compliance for people with disabilities at the beach, [the Long Island Rail Road] and in the business district in the village.”

A former Southampton resident, Wendy Wagner, had worked with Mr. Murtha to make more areas accessible for the handicapped for 17 years, beginning when he was mayor Southampton Village. “He was an amazing man,” she said. “He was totally committed to the project.”

One of the things he would say, she said, was “Someday, everything will be accessible, and nobody will think about any of this.”

The last time she saw Mr. Murtha, who had Alzheimer’s disease, he told her that he did not know who he was.

“I said, ‘Doug, you’re a great man and everyone loves you,’” she said.

Along with serving as the mayor of Southampton, Mr. Murtha was a member of the Southampton Rotary Club, Kiwanis and Southampton Little League. He loved playing golf and boating, and he was a huge New York Giants fan.

At a Southampton Village Board meeting on June 9, current Southampton Village Mayor Mark Epley noted the death of Mr. Murtha, who had lived right down the block.

“He loved Southampton and was a good community guy,” Mr. Epley said. “He will be missed, but I know he’s in a better place.”

In addition to his wife, sons, and two brothers, Bob and Gary, Mr. Murtha is survived by three grandchildren, Cadence, Kaia and Madeleine.

You May Also Like:

A Solution

The traffic disaster is caused mainly by huge trucks, not passenger cars, and not by local residents. Here is the solution. Eastbound: Add a new third high-occupancy vehicle lane on Sunrise Highway from Westhampton Beach to the start of County Road 39. Ban all trucks over 10,000 pounds from the HOV and middle lanes along that new three-lane section, and ban all trucks over 10,000 pounds from the left lane on existing County Road 39 all the way to the diner in Southampton in both directions. Left lane on County Road 39 for vehicles under 10,000 pounds only. Westbound: Ban ... 28 Apr 2025 by Staff Writer

Blinding Hypocrisy

Jesse Warren for supervisor? Really? That’s what the psychotically ambitious former mayor of Southampton Village recently proposed to the local Republican leadership. The inverted symmetry of it is striking. Current Town Supervisor Maria Moore, with a successful term behind her, had been the acclaimed mayor of Westhampton Beach Village before, credited with a major downtown restoration and the installation of a transformative sewer system. Jesse Warren, currently out of office, was the mayor of Southampton Village, remembered for little except the constant acrimony with the village trustees that finally drove him from office. A race between Moore and Warren could ... by Staff Writer

Come Together

Hampton Bays is the embodiment of the “Cheers” theme song: It’s a place “where everybody knows your name.” If I describe Hampton Bays to someone not from here, it’s compared to Stars Hollow in “Gilmore Girls” or a small town you see in a Hallmark Christmas movie. But, as Bob Dylan said, the times, they are a-changing. We are a small hamlet with a big heart. When one of us is suffering, we rally together. When one of us succeeds, we all succeed. This is what makes Hampton Bays so special. The people and the community here care so much ... by Staff Writer

Two Sets of Rules

Southampton Village Mayor Bill Manger rammed through a bloated $37 million annual budget, the largest in Southampton Village history. Spending continues to spiral out of control, up another $1.2 million this year alone, on top of the $2.1 million increase the year before. There is no discipline, no plan and no regard for the taxpayers who are footing the bill. He said that there would be no increase in taxes. That was untruthful. Village taxes will increase by a quarter of a million dollars. Also, this budget fails to account for the lifetime health care and other benefits that Bill ... by Staff Writer

Positive Actions

Denunciation by recitation would not stand up in court, nor should it in the court of public opinion. Without the strengths of context, evidence or sources, Carol Scott’s Letter to the Editor [“Bad for Southampton,” Letters, April 24] unfairly maligns Gordon Herr and, indirectly, the elected officials he has supported over the years. This prime example of poor opinion-shaping requires a response. Higher taxes: Reports from various local news sources inform that pension and health costs challenge public budgets in all five East End towns. Note: Past Democratic supervisors received high marks and lower bond rates from credit rating agencies ... by Staff Writer

How Did This Happen?

If I had a dollar for every person who has called, emailed or stopped me on a village street in the past two weeks to express their outrage over the solar canopy erected in the Jobs Lane parking lot, I would be a very wealthy man. From young to old, lifelong residents to newcomers, their overwhelming sentiment is one of confusion and deep disappointment. And questions. Lots of questions. “How did this happen?” “Who made that decision?” “Did the ARB approve this?” “Why didn’t we know?” As co-chair of the village’s environmental committee, I applaud installation of renewable energy equipment ... by Staff Writer

Finding a Balance

A two-page spread in the current issue of New York magazine is headlined: “Where Is Our Post-Car City?” The subhead: “We need to be building right now. Instead, we’re stuck in traffic.” The piece details many non-realized ideas over the years to provide more means of mass transportation in the city. There have been many ideas on Long Island, too, to encourage public transit. A former presiding officer of the Suffolk County Legislature, Lou Howard, promoted for years a plan for a monorail running in the center of the Long Island Expressway. It didn’t get anywhere. And the cost to ... by Karl Grossman

Not a Joke

Just last week, the Southampton Town Democratic Party’s vice chair, who jokingly described herself as Chairman Gordon Herr’s “henchwoman,” went after a former elected official and a former Southampton Town Planning Board member [“Beware of Grudges,” Letters, April 24]. Why? They dared to speak out about Gordon’s alleged backroom deals, especially in light of The Southampton Press’s own editorial criticizing the party boss for eliminating choice in this November’s town elections [“Under Attack,” Editorial, April 17]. This appears to be his playbook: trying to silence anyone who questions the power structure through public attacks, bullying and intimidation. I personally experienced ... by Staff Writer

You've Been Duped

I’d like to respond to Andi Klausner’s recent letter [“Beware of Grudges,” Letters, April 24], in which she assumed the role of grifter Gordon Herr’s “henchwoman.” Andi, you’re not the henchwoman — you’re the patsy. Andi’s letter got me thinking: Why would a well-respected activist, mother, wife, Housing Authority commissioner and vice chair of the Democratic Committee lie to Southampton voters about the existence of a cross-party endorsement deal admitted to and corroborated by both the Republicans and Conservatives? The answer? She wouldn’t — she isn’t a liar. Then, the epiphany came: Like the rest of the committee, Andi didn’t ... by Staff Writer

Not Welcome

Consider this a public thank you to Charles McArdle, Southampton Town highway superintendent. Mr. McArdle is one of very few elected officials to actually work for the people who elected him and not for an out-of-town, private corporation that has decimated the Pine Barrens under which flows our drinking water. Discovery Land has bamboozled and/or confused most of our elected officials, to say nothing of the unelected Planning Board. Now, despite the fact that on their original planning documents Spinney Road is clearly labeled as a town road and not a dirt path, as Jessica Insalaco of Discovery has decreed ... by Staff Writer