MacPherson Gets 4 To 12 Years For Role In Mortgage Fraud Case - 27 East
logo logo logo logo

Southampton Press / Community / 1608465

MacPherson Gets 4 To 12 Years For Role In Mortgage Fraud Case

icon 2 Photos
Donald MacPherson

Donald MacPherson

Donald MacPherson

Donald MacPherson

By Erin McKinley on Feb 27, 2012

Donald MacPherson was sentenced to four to 12 years in prison Monday morning, having pleaded guilty late last year to multiple felony charges related to an $82 million mortgage fraud scheme targeting the East End that involved former Suffolk County Legislator George O. Guldi.

Mr. MacPherson, 68, also was ordered by Suffolk County Court Judge James F.X. Doyle to pay back $44 million to the lending institutions that he cheated as part of the scam, according to Robert Clifford, a spokesman for Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota. Mr. MacPherson was ordered to pay back the money as part of 34 restitution judgment orders.

“J.P. Morgan Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo and other lenders were swindled by this defendant and his associates who arranged for the filing of mortgage applications that were filled with fraud, specifically false employer information supplied to straw purchasers, forged notary signatures, and falsified powers of attorney and fictional bank balances,” Mr. Spota said in a prepared statement.

“Every one of these mortgages for some 60 homes ended up in default,” he continued. “The defendants’ greed inflicted massive economic damage to the banking industry and the regional economy.”

Mr. MacPherson, the former owner of Magic’s Pub in Westhampton Beach, pleaded guilty in November to 45 felonies, including grand larceny, insurance fraud, possession of a forged instrument and scheme to defraud. Over the summer, Mr. MacPherson, who has homes in both Westhampton Beach and Manhattan, rejected a plea bargain in which he would have served between 28 months and seven years in prison for his role in the crime.

Following his sentencing on Monday, Mr. MacPherson was remanded to the Suffolk County Jail in Riverside. He will eventually be transferred to a prison in upstate New York.

Mr. MacPherson’s wife, Carrie Coakley, pleaded guilty in December to two felony counts of grand larceny and fraud for her role in the scheme. She is expected to be sentenced next Thursday, March 8, pending the completion of a Suffolk County Department or Probation pre-sentencing report.

Mr. Guldi, a Democrat and longtime county legislator, was also a co-defendant in the mortgage fraud case and was sentenced to one to three years in prison last year for his role. That sentence will run concurrently with a four- to 12-year sentence he received last March for an unrelated insurance fraud case in which he was found guilty of misusing insurance funds after a fire gutted his family home in Westhampton Beach.

Related Stories

You May Also Like:

Sagg Scene

For years, there hasn’t been much of a scene in Sagaponack. The Little Red Schoolhouse is delightful, and sometimes so is the Village Hall. An artist’s garden, a writer’s abode — much of the locations are private, or feel so. The name of this column even changed. In the duration by which the rural economy transformed from agricultural to housing, we also sustained a severe downward trend in Sagg’s year-round community. This change was sadly mirrored about a decade ago, when, after 120 years in business, the Sagaponack General Store became seasonal, too. There is a scene in Sagaponack now. ... 22 Apr 2025 by Marilee Foster

Failing To Plan Is Planning To Fail

An issue for decades, affordable housing for local residents on the South Fork, has reached crisis proportions. The crisis has accelerated in the wake of the pandemic. The value of real estate sales tripled between 2019 and 2021. High prices and low inventory has put housing beyond the reach of more and more local residents. The housing crisis is not unique to the South Fork — it is a national issue. Housing costs are part of an affordability problem that has upended politics across the nation. Middle class Americans who get up every morning and go to work in search ... 21 Apr 2025 by Fred Thiele

On Being American

Down but not out, John Avlon wants to be part of reversing the democratic — and Democratic — recession in America. His ideas, heavy on unity and the promise of “economic abundance,” free of revenge and insults, and light on blame and political recrimination, feel like they’re from another era in this time of chaos, corruption and cruelty. Little wonder, seeing as the media personality, author and recent Democratic congressional candidate is also a historian who spends some portion of his days examining America’s leaders in our darkest days to know how to step out and lead amid this existential ... by Biddle Duke

Much Less Green

The administration of President Donald Trump is making an unbridled push to block renewable energy projects — including, last week, halting the placement of 54 wind turbines in the ocean south of Long Island — and is pushing fossil fuels, among them, coal. The burning of fossil fuels is the leading cause of climate change. Trump has repeatedly called climate change a “hoax.” Meanwhile, Suffolk County resident Lee Zeldin of Shirley, administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, is canceling, on a sweeping basis, environmental regulations, discharging EPA employees, and, last week, stopping the collection of greenhouse gas emission data. Further, ... by Karl Grossman

School News, April 24, Southampton Town

Junior Tri-M Induction Ceremony Hampton Bays Middle School recently inducted new members into the Junior ... by Staff Writer

Earth Day Celebration at SOFO on Saturday

The South Fork Natural History Museum’s annual Earth Day Celebration will take place Saturday, April 26, from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. at the museum on Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike in Bridgehampton. From 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. there will be an array of children’s activities. A birding for beginners walk will start at 10:30 a.m., as well as face painting. From 2 to 3 p.m., the Evelyn Alexander Wildlife Rescue Center will show off some of its animal ambassadors. Admission is $5 for members, $12 for nonmembers. For more information, visit sofo.org. by Staff Writer

'Rocking for the Homeless' This Saturday

“Rocking for the Homeless,” a benefit concert for Maureen’s Haven Homeless Outreach, will be held on Saturday, April 26, at 6 p.m. at Riverhead Moose Lodge, 28 Lincoln Street, Riverhead. The night of music and dancing will feature The Vinyl Rockers, Who Are Those Guys, and Gene Casey & The Lone Sharks. Food, door prizes, and raffles are also planned. For tickets, which are almost sold out, go to maureenshaven.org. by Staff Writer

Kiwanas Golf Outing Is June 9

The annual golf outing hosted by the Kiwanis Club of Southampton is set for Monday, June 9, at The Rock Golf Club in Wading River. The Flying Point Foundation for Autism will be a beneficiary of the event, as well as other Kiwanis activities and programs. The driving range opens at 11 a.m. as will check-in and lunch. Tee off is at 12:30 p.m. with a Texas scramble format. Beer and soda will be available on the course. Cocktails, a raw bar, and dinner will follow. During dinner, awards will be presented and raffle winners selected. Sponsors are also being ... by Staff Writer

Free Mammograms at Child Care Center

Stony Brook Hospital will be offering free mammograms for women age 40 and older at the Bridgehampton Child Care & Recreational Center on Tuesday, April 29, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. The center is located at 551 Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton. Appointments are required and may be made by emailing Camryn@bhccrc.org with name, date of birth, phone number and email. Or call Camryn Highsmith at 631-537-0616 ext. 105. by Staff Writer

Civic Association To Meet on April 28

The Hampton Bays Civic Association will hold its monthly meeting on Monday, April 28, at the Hampton Bays Community Center on Ponquogue Avenue. Doors open at 6:30 p.m. for the 7 p.m. meeting. The guest speakers will be Hampton Bays School District Superintendent Lars Clemensen and Business Administrator Lawrence Luce. They will discuss the district’s proposed budget for the 2025-26 school year. by Staff Writer