Peter H. Tooker of Bridgehampton Dies February 26 - 27 East

Sag Harbor Express

Peter H. Tooker of Bridgehampton Dies February 26

icon 1 Photo
Peter H. Tooker

Peter H. Tooker

authorStaff Writer on Mar 2, 2023

Peter H. Tooker, a long-time resident of Bridgehampton, died on February 26 at the East End Hospice Kanas Center for Hospice Care on Quiogue, after a long struggle with illness.

He was born on May 8, 1947, and raised in Port Jefferson. He attended Adelphi University, graduating with a degree in art, despite being colorblind. He was a substitute art teacher for several years for grade school students around Long Island.

Tooker spent his summers and weekends at his stepmother’s house in Bridgehampton. For pocket money, he worked in restaurants, such as the Bulls Head in Bridgehampton (now Topping Rose) and bars, like Mitty’s General Store, the area’s first disco, located on Montauk Highway in Water Mill and The Moon, another disco, in East Hampton. Seeing that he could earn more and have more fun in these kinds of establishments, he turned his back on teaching and became the barkeep at The American Hotel in Sag Harbor, a position he held for over 20 years, leaving around 1990.

During his tenure at The Hotel, he participated in its transition from a local watering hole to the fine-dining French restaurant it is today. At his bar, Tooker served writers such as Wilfrid Sheed (“The Boys of Winter: A Novel”), Truman Capote (“In Cold Blood”), and Tom Harris (“Silence of the Lambs”), and actors such as Michael Caine, Michelle Pfeiffer, (both of whom were in Sag Harbor filming Alan Alda’s “Sweet Liberty”) and Eli Wallach, on whom he accidentally spilled an Irish coffee. One of Tooker’s prized possessions was a photo showing himself, in profile, standing in the doorway to the hotel porch, with Pfeiffer and Caine seated, looking out onto Main Street.

In 1992, Tooker and Claudia Ward moved to Manhattan, and he began his final career in property management, managing their apartment, her house in North Haven, and his stepmother’s house, as well as his own in Bridgehampton. Tooker and Ward married in July 1994, after having been together for over five years.

The couple moved permanently to Bridgehampton in 2009, when they established a photography company, Hayground Photos, Inc. They could be found shooting local events like the first (in a long time) soap box derby in Sag Harbor, the aftermath of Super Storm Sandy, antique car fairs, post-hurricane surfing below Camp Hero’s bluffs in Montauk, and lots of their travels here and abroad. They sold their work at art fairs around the Tri-State area.

In addition to his wife Claudia, he is survived by his Beyer cousins, Bob (Monument, Colorado), Bruce (Sag Harbor), Brad (Amagansett), and Bill (Franklin, Tenesse).

A celebration of his life will be held on a later date.

Memorial gifts may be made to the Westhampton Care Center (westhamptonrehab.com) or the East End Hospice Kanas Center for Hospice Care (eeh.org), in memory of Peter H. Tooker.

You May Also Like:

Sag Harbor Businesses Say They See More Visitors, but Fewer Customers

Downtown Sag Harbor was packed last summer, with pedestrians crowding the sidewalks, and cars crowding ... 5 Feb 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Long Island's Last Ducks?

The destruction of nearly 100,000 ducks at Crescent Duck Farm in Aquebogue late last month due to an outbreak of the avian flu there was alarming, and a tragedy for the family running the farm and their employees. It’s unclear whether the last remaining duck farm on Long Island will be able to rebound. The outbreak at the farm was the latest in a series of scary global outbreaks in recent months, affecting the poultry industry and resulting in a sharp increase in cost to consumers. Locally, it follows an outbreak of the deadly virus at Spring Farm, a game ... by Editorial Board

Throw a Lifeline

The first two weeks of the second Donald Trump administration have been a fire hose of developments “flooding the zone,” so it’s easy to miss small developments that could have enormous impact in some quarters. One of those is the Federal Communications Commission and its new focus on NPR and PBS. The New York Times reported that FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has launched an investigation into “whether the news organizations’ member stations violated government rules by recognizing financial sponsors on the air.” Its conclusions could lead Congress to take away financial support. NPR and PBS acknowledge corporate sponsors on air, ... by Editorial Board

Sag Harbor Woman Loses $200,000 in Crypto Fraud

A Sag Harbor woman was defrauded out of more than $200,000 since the summer, when a fraudster first reached out to her via social media. The victim reported to Sag Harbor Village Police last Thursday afternoon that a man she knew only as David had begun communicating with her through Instagram. He encouraged her to invest money online through Coinbase and Cash App, telling her the cash would then be converted to cryptocurrency. Over several months she did so, transferring $170,500 from her checking account into Coinbase. The money would then be used to buy bitcoin, the profits from which ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Town Will Embark on New Comprehensive Plan

The Southampton Town Board and the town’s planning staff are embarking on the likely years-long ... by Michael Wright

Historian John Strong, a Fierce Ally of Native Nations, Dies at 89

When Tela Troge was in high school, she saw an advertisement for a lecture by ... by Michelle Trauring

2015 Southampton Town United Girls Compete, Promote Goodwill in Bahamas

While most of their peers were dealing with frigid temperatures on the South Fork, a ... 4 Feb 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Hoops Snaps Losing Streak; Mariners, 'Canes Compete at Paul Dilorio Wrestling Tourney

Win Over Harborfields Snaps Seven-Game Skid A 67-34 victory at home over Harborfields on January 27 snapped what had been a seven-game losing streak for the East Hampton boys basketball team (4-10 in League V, 6-12 overall). Toby Foster led Bonac with 22 points, Miles Menu added 14, Mason Jefferson scored 11 and Carter Dickinson chipped in with eight. The Bonackers did lose their most recent game, 75-71, at Half Hollow Hills West on January 30. Mariners Topple Host Port Jeff The Southampton boys basketball team defeated host Port Jefferson, 89-33, on January 30. Alex Franklin finished with a game-high 19 points, ... by Staff Writer

East Hampton Hosts Successful Sink Pink Game; Pierson Clinches Playoff Spot After Defeating Port Jeff Monday

For the second year in a row, the East Hampton girls basketball team hosted its ... by Drew Budd

East Hampton Wrestling Honors Its Seniors at Bonac Duals

The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton wrestling team head coach Ethan Mitchell would like to say the Bonac ... by Drew Budd