Phyllis S. Toohey Of Southampton Dies September 6

icon 1 Photo
Phyllis S. Toohey

Phyllis S. Toohey

authorStaff Writer on Sep 12, 2022

Phyllis S. Toohey of New York City and Southampton died on September 6. She was 91.

She was born in Jersey City on August 6, 1931, to Ruth Selina Goldey and Charles Scheidecker. She was a member of the Barnard College Class of 1953, attended New York University’s School of Interior Design and successfully ran her eponymous interior design business for many years.

She met her husband of more than 60 years, Edward J. Toohey, at a high school graduation party in the late 1940s. They lived up and down the East Coast and built lifelong friendships from Camp Lejeune, Washington, D.C., and Palm Beach, to New Haven, New York City and Southampton.

Toohey was an ardent supporter of cultural and environmental institutions in New York City and eastern Long Island, her family said, loved to swim, cross country ski and dance, and was a fiercely loyal and supportive wife, mother, grandmother, great grandmother, cousin and friend.

She had impeccable style, her family said, and was amazingly gentle, kind and elegant — traits that belied an intense strength that helped her persevere and build a remarkable life characterized by bringing together those closest to her for a meal, a weekend and, in some cases, a lifetime.

Known as “Mime” to those closest to her, she was predeceased by her husband Ed and daughter Karen T. Hughes. She is survived by her grandchildren Alexandra and Andrew (Eliza); her three great-grandchildren; son-in-law Jeff; and extended family and friends.

A memorial service is planned for September 16 at 10:30 a.m. at St. Andrew’s Dune Church in Southampton.

In lieu of flowers, the family requests that donations be made in her memory to the Peconic Baykeeper, P.O. Box 939, Hampton Bays, NY 11946.

You May Also Like:

Protests Over ICE Detentions Continue To Ripple Across South Fork

Protests over the detention of at least a dozen people by federal immigration agents in ... 15 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Arrest Made in Amagansett Hit-and-Run That Left Pedestrian Seriously Injured

An Amagansett woman suffered serious injuries when she was struck by a car on Montauk ... by Staff Writer

Brown Budda Opens Cannabis Shop in Southampton, but Town Threatens Court Action

Southampton Town has threatened to take a second cannabis dispensary to court because the business ... 14 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Benjamin ‘Shonowe’ Kellis Haile of the Shinnecock Nation Dies November 12

Benjamin “Shonowe” Kellis Haile of the Shinnecock Nation died on November 12 in Southampton. He was 60. A complete obituary will appear in a future edition of The Press. by Staff Writer

Westhampton Beach Fire Department Extinguishes Car Fire

The Westhampton Beach Fire Department was paged out for a car fire just north of ... by Staff Writer

Growing Wellness: New Community Garden at Stony Brook Southampton To Offer 'Produce Prescriptions'

Since its creation, the Food Lab at Stony Brook Southampton has been committed to studying ... by Cailin Riley

In Wake of Immigration Detentions, Advocacy Group Is Left With Many Holes To Plug

While the ICE sweep last week that ensnared a dozen immigrants has sparked outrage and ... 13 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Bars Over Southampton Village Hall Windows, Former Jail Cells, Will Be Removed

For some unlucky people, the workplace can feel like a prison. There’s no reason to ... by Cailin Riley

Cleaning Out

There is no setting on binoculars that works in the fog — everything in the distance remains indistinct, and that is fine. Here, the low place, called Sagg Swamp, begins a nearly uninterrupted corridor of unbuilt-upon land: wetlands, ponds and kettleholes; the Long Pond Greenbelt runs for miles to the old harbor. Today, contained, the only fog is there. It rises up from the dark muck to smudge the damp foliage with its dreamy, silver light. So, above, as the crow flies, the air is tinted between gold and pink. Fog is a reoccurring theme, because it reveals a sense ... by Marilee Foster

'Novembrance'

Gaudy October is gone. The November landscape is muted colors, falling leaves and skeletal branches. The month opens with reminders of death. In the Catholic Church, November first is All Saints’ Day. On November 2, All Souls Day is dedicated to praying for the souls of the departed. The Mexican tradition of the Day of the Dead is celebrated on the same days but has a more festive air. It’s also observed across the United States. The All-Souls Procession has been an annual event since 1990 in Tucson, Arizona. San Antonio, Texas, is known for its Muertos Fest and river ... by Denise Gray Meehan