Rare Orange Lobster Discovered At Cor-J's Finds A New Home

icon 4 Photos
The orange lobster out of the tank and on it's way to Brooklyn. DEBBIE TUMA

The orange lobster out of the tank and on it's way to Brooklyn. DEBBIE TUMA

The lobster as it was transported to New York Aquarium, in a cooler on a bed of ice, seaweed and sea lettuce. DEBBIE TUMA

The lobster as it was transported to New York Aquarium, in a cooler on a bed of ice, seaweed and sea lettuce. DEBBIE TUMA

William Hana of the New York Aquarium, left, and Neil Hanrahan of Cor-J Seafood Market getting the orange lobster ready for the trip to Brooklyn. DEBBIE TUMA

William Hana of the New York Aquarium, left, and Neil Hanrahan of Cor-J Seafood Market getting the orange lobster ready for the trip to Brooklyn. DEBBIE TUMA

The orange lobster in his new home at the New York Aquarium. WILLIAM HANNA

The orange lobster in his new home at the New York Aquarium. WILLIAM HANNA

By Debbie Tuma on Sep 21, 2020

A rare, bright orange lobster that was discovered at Cor-J Seafood Market in Hampton Bays about a month ago has found a permanent home at the New York Aquarium in Brooklyn. William Hana, director of the animal program at the aquarium, drove out from Brooklyn on September 12 to pick up the lobster, which he described as “one in 30 million.”

Jimmy Coronesi, the owner of Cor-J Seafood Market, said in his 30 years there, he has never seen an orange lobster, which showed up in a shipment from Maine. He didn’t want to throw it back in the ocean for fear it would get eaten by predators, and he felt it should be somehow displayed.

“A creature as rare as this should be cherished and kept so people can see it and appreciate it,” he said.

So he decided to keep it in hopes of finding an aquarium to take it. Atlantis Marine World in Riverhead turned it down because they already had two orange lobsters, plus a blue and a red one. The Mystic Aquarium in Mystic, Connecticut did the same, as they already had two orange lobsters, two blue ones, and a calico one.

But Mr. Hana, who was formerly the curator of fish and invertebrates at the Mystic Seaport Aquarium, until recently, said the New York Aquarium was happy to take it because they currently have a spiny lobster, but not an orange lobster, which they can use for educational purposes.

Mr. Hana took the “golden lobster,” as he called it, out of Cor-J’s holding tank and placed it in a larger cooler, on a bed of ice, seaweed and sea lettuce. Then he set it in the back of his New York Aquarium SUV.

“We need to keep it comfortable, so the seaweed will cushion it, and give it moisture,” he said. “When it gets to the New York Aquarium, we will put it in a holding tank, with the same temperature, about 45 to 50 degrees Farenheit, and it will have to be quarantined for 30 days.”

He said this is to make sure the crustacean doesn’t have parasites. Mr. Hana also explained that the orange crustacean will likely be put in an isolated tank because “lobsters don’t do well with other species, and they also compete with other lobsters, for space.”

“They are not social animals … they come together mainly to mate,” he said. “The idea is to keep it happy, and create an environment to make it comfortable, with a cave, a rock pile, and vegetation that it can hide in.”

It will be fed a seafood diet, with a variety of fish, shrimp and clams. Right now, the lobster is about a pound and a three quarters, but Mr. Hana said it is in the molting stage, which means it is growing bigger.

With lobster catches on Long Island getting smaller due to the warming of the waters, Mr. Hana said more lobsters are being caught in the northern waters of New England and Nova Scotia. He said while at the Mystic Aquarium, “We had so many orange lobsters available that we couldn’t take anymore.”

Noel Heinsohn, director of aquaculture at the Atlantis Marine World Aquarium in Riverhead, said his facility has had about a dozen calls from other people who have found them as well. “For some reason, there was an up-tick in the population, and orange lobsters have been showing up more this year,” he said.

He said the lobsters become bright orange through genetics — the coloring is a dormant trait.

“Out of each spawn, they have the potential to have one orange one, but they get picked up by predators because of their noticeable, bright orange color,” he said. “They are able to live 80 to 100 years. Although rare, they are found throughout the entire Northeast Coast.”

Mr. Hana explained that Cor-J’s orange lobster will be used for outreach and environmental programs.

“When people think of lobsters, they think of dinner, but I believe this unique one will be an ambassador, to teach New York residents and visitors about the natural local area and the need for protection and conservation,” he said.

For further information, visit the New York Aquarium website at nyaquarium.org or the Wildlife Conservation Society website at wcs.org.

You May Also Like:

East Quogue Residents, Environmental Advocates Condemn Condo Proposal at Dockers Site

Residents of East Quogue this past week leveled harsh assessments of the latest evidence in ... 8 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Southampton Scored $19 Million Grant for Riverside Sewers

Southampton Town has been awarded a $19 million grant to help fund the construction of a sewer system and sewage treatment plant for Riverside — the cornerstone of the town’s decade-long drive for a sweeping revitalization of the blighted hamlet. The town recently won a lawsuit brought by Riverhead Town seeking to stop the Riverside sewer system, which will be able to treat the daily sewage from more than 700 new residences and hundreds of thousands of square feet of new commercial businesses. The first phase of the design and planing for the sewer system is complete and the town ... 5 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Southampton Town Directs $5 Million To Preserving Marshlands in Western Shinnecock Bay

The Town of Southampton will dedicate nearly $5 million from the Community Preservation Fund to ... 29 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

After Cellphone Ban, Group for the East End Encourages Kids To Get Outside and Explore

Earlier this month, Jen Skilbred, the assistant director for environmental education with the Group for ... 26 Oct 2025 by Cailin Riley

Court Tosses Riverhead Challenge to Riverside Sewage Treatment Plant

A Suffolk County Supreme Court judge this week threw out a lawsuit filed by Riverhead ... 8 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

Leader of Othodox Christians To Visit Southampton, Bless Shinnecock Bay

The religious leader of Orthodox Christianity, His All-Holiness Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, will visit the East ... 19 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Group for East End Osprey Survey Shows More Nests but Fewer Fledglings

Ospreys, or fish hawks, the birds whose population was decimated by the use of the ... 15 Sep 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Southampton Town Agrees To Buy 2.5-Acre Waterfront Parcel in North Haven for $15 Million

The Southampton Town Board on September 9 agreed to spend $15 million from its Community ... 11 Sep 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Collaboration, Reclamation and Hope: The Story of a Scientific Triumph on Shinnecock Bay

When Shinnecock Bay was designated as a “Hope Spot” in 2022 by Mission Blue — ... by Cailin Riley

Tupper Boathouse Renovation Work in North Sea Is Ready To Begin

The leaders of the effort to restore the Tupper Boathouse on North Sea Harbor say ... 10 Sep 2025 by Michael Wright