Silver’s Restaurant In Southampton Closes Its Doors After 96 Years - 27 East

Silver’s Restaurant In Southampton Closes Its Doors After 96 Years

icon 2 Photos
Silver's restaurant closes after 96 years in business.

Silver's restaurant closes after 96 years in business.

Silver's restaurant closes after 96 years in business, the art in the building is currently for sale.

Silver's restaurant closes after 96 years in business, the art in the building is currently for sale. RACHEL VALDESPINO

authorStaff Writer on Oct 22, 2019

After nearly a century of service, Silver’s restaurant on Main Street in Southampton Village has closed its doors.

“After 96 years in business — of which I’ve personally been involved for 57 years, of running a successful and gratifying business — I thank all our friends and patrons for good will, and our success,” said owner Garrett Wellins.

The luncheonette space has gone through its fair share of changes, starting off as a cigar shop, then transitioning into a clothing store, and finally progressing into the restaurant the village patronized for the past five decades.

Silver’s first opened in 1923, in its first iteration as a cigar shop, and was run by Max and Mollie Silver — the original location is next door, where Southampton Cheese Shoppe is today.

In 1955, Garrett’s father, Daniel Wellins, bought the restaurant from his maternal grandparents. The Wellinses were tailors in Southampton, and Silver’s was turned into a clothing shop after falling on hard times.

Silver’s transitioned into a restaurant in 1966 and moved into its current location in the 1970s.

After 57 years in the family business, Garrett Wellins planned to retire in September 2018 and put the business up for sale. His son, Ryan Wellins, planned to take over the luncheonette after the threat of the business’s leaving the family became imminent. He ultimately decided that he did not want to take over the restaurant business, and Garrett Wellins decided to sell it, which he has successfully done. The new tenants, whom he didn’t identify, will be moving in this December.

Silver’s stopped serving lunch earlier this month. Artwork that has been on display in the restaurant throughout its long life is currently for sale. Those interested can stop by the restaurant and take a look, while they last.

The collection includes oil paintings, Russian samovars, and a variety of books.

You May Also Like:

John M. Connolly of Hampton Bays Dies May 16

John Martin Connolly, a longtime resident of Hampton Bays, died peacefully on May 16, surrounded ... 22 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Richard W. ‘Dick’ Kuhn Sr., Formerly of Hampton Bays, Dies May 14

Richard William “Dick” Kuhn Sr. died on May 14 at The Chelsea at Brookhaven assisted ... by Staff Writer

Coopers Named No. 1 Beach in the U.S. Again; Main Beach Ranked Fifth Best

Coopers Beach in Southampton Village was named the best beach in the United States, and ... by Michael Wright

UPDATE: Missing Flanders Woman Found Dead

UPDATE: Southampton Town Police say that the Flanders woman who had been reported missing on ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of May 22

SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — Tayah Rae Coffey, 25, of Southampton was arrested by Southampton Village Police at about 3:45 a.m. on May 9 and charged with DWI, a misdemeanor, after police were alerted by the BMW emergency response crash alert system that a vehicle had crashed on Miller Road. SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — A Vermont woman was arrested by Southampton Village Police and charged with petit larceny, a misdemeanor, after she refused to pay a New York City taxi driver the $628.25 fare he said she owed for a ride from Lower Manhattan to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital, on May 11. Police ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Town's Latest — and Hopefully Last — Draft of New BESS Codes | 27 Speaks Podcast

With renewable energy sources like solar farms and windmills gaining traction on the East End, ... by 27Speaks

Southampton Teen Builds Free Library at Train Station for Eagle Scout Project

As the highest rank offered by Scouts BSA, formerly known as the Boy Scouts, Eagle ... by Dan Stark

Tierney, Task Force Launch Aqua Alert System for East End Waterways

Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond Tierney held a press conference at Coast Guard Station Shinnecock ... 21 May 2025 by Dan Stark

DIY Weather Forecasting

“Remarkably Stupid” — Craig McLean, former 
NOAA director of research, describing the closure 
of key ... by Jenny Noble

With County Title Officially Wrapped Up, Bees Prepare for June 5 Regional Semifinal

The Bridgehampton/Ross baseball team is officially the Suffolk County Class C Champions after finishing the ... by Drew Budd