State Troopers Seek Information In Shooting Death Of Sag Harbor Man On Shinnecock Territory - 27 East

State Troopers Seek Information In Shooting Death Of Sag Harbor Man On Shinnecock Territory

icon 1 Photo
State Police are investigating a shooting on the Shinnecock Territory.

State Police are investigating a shooting on the Shinnecock Territory.

Kitty Merrill on Nov 8, 2021

A Sag Harbor man who was found unresponsive on the Shinnecock Nation Territory Friday night and later died was the victim of a shooting, according to New York State Police, who are investigating the homicide.

With the investigation still in its earliest stages, by Tuesday evening police had determined the shooting took place where the victim, 43-year-old Ali Wisdom, was found. Police offered few details about the investigation.

Troopers were called to the territory on the night of Friday, November 5, at about 9:52 p.m., following reports of a man lying on Old Point Road, according to a release issued on Monday evening.

Responding officers found Wisdom and determined he had been shot. He was transported to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital, where he died from his injuries.

Wisdom, who was not a member of the Shinnecock Nation, had previous interactions with local law enforcement. He was accused of going to his cousin’s house on Hillside Drive West in Sag Harbor one night in February 2015. There, he brandished a gun, pointed at the victim’s head, and demanded money, authorities said at the time. Thwarted, he fired several rounds into a television. As the victim escaped, Wisdom fired another shot out the window. He apparently left the country following the shooting.

Wisdom was apprehended trying to get back into the United States from Mexico almost a month later. Suffolk County’s fugitive squad traveled to San Diego to collect Wisdom, who was met at the airport in Queens by Sag Harbor Village Police.

Wisdom was charged with robbery in the first degree, criminal use of a firearm in the first degree, reckless endangerment in the first degree, and criminal mischief in the third degree. He was also charged with a misdemeanor count of menacing in the second degree. He spent time in prison for the offenses. Authorities said they learned of his return locally last month.

His family released a statement on Tuesday night: “Ali Wisdom paid his debt to society and came home to Sag Harbor to spend time with his loving family, rebuilding his life and looking forward to a promising music and art career. His family and community are deeply saddened that he did not have the opportunity [to] pursue his dreams and continue as a productive member of society.”

Wisdom was planning to release a new album under his stage name, Columbo The Shining Star. The family said they are praying for justice and plan to complete his artistic work and set up a scholarship in his name at his alma mater, Howard University, for students from areas impacted by racial and economic disparities.

Bryan Polite, chairman of the Shinnecock Council of Trustees offered a statement late Tuesday afternoon. “The Council of Trustees are taking this matter very seriously,” he said. “We’ve been in contact with the New York State Police and defer all questions regarding the investigation to the New York State Police.”

Old Point Road runs south along the eastern side of the peninsula that the territory lies on. According to former tribal chairman Lance Gumbs, wisdom’s body was found about three quarters of the way down Old Point Road.

“Nobody knows what happened,” Gumbs said. “It’s a tragic thing.”

Gumbs said that while Wisdom was described as not a member of the Shinnecock Nation, he has family on the territory. “I’ve known him since he was a little boy," he said. "He was friend to many people up here. He was not a stranger to the community.”

By Tuesday night, the tribe had met twice to discuss the tragedy, Gumbs reported. “We met to voice our condolences to the family and vented our frustration in the community because there are no answers. There is no ‘why?’”

“This young man didn’t deserve to die like that,” he said.

State Police are asking for anyone with information regarding the homicide to call 631-756-3300 or Suffolk County Crime Stoppers anonymously at 800- 220-TIPS. Crime Stoppers offers a cash reward for information that leads to an arrest.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of April 3

HAMPTON BAYS — A Hampton Bays man was arrested by Southampton Town Police on April 1 in connection with a March 9 theft of a boat trailer from an East Quogue property. Anthony Colonna, 29, was charged with grand larceny, a felony, and conspiracy to commit a crime, a misdemeanor, for his role in the theft of the trailer, which was valued at $8,000. Police had previously arrested a Medford man, Christian Klemm, 29, in connection with the crime, who was charged with two felonies for possession of stolen property and grand larceny. 2 Apr 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton DWI Arrests for the Week of April 3

Enrique F. Diaz Chocho, 36, of Flanders was arrested just after 6 p.m. on March 29 and charged with DWI after Southampton Town Police officers responded to a report of a two-car accident on Flanders Road near Red Creek Road and found Chocho had been driving one of the vehicles in an intoxicated condition. Nicholas Davis, 18, of Hampton Bays was arrested just after midnight on March 29 and charged with DWI after he was involved in a one-car crash on Oaktree Lane in East Quogue and was determined by a responding Southampton Town Police officer to have been drinking ... by Staff Writer

The Mountain

Southampton Town officials, it must be said, are very much on point when it comes to affordable housing. It’s not just lip service: The town is doing its level best to begin to address the ongoing crisis that is making it harder for the town’s workforce to stay here, and more difficult for the town’s business community to fill positions. It became problematic a few years ago, but today it’s probably the biggest issue Town Hall faces. And it appears that all hands are on deck. The town’s voters also have done their part, approving a new Community Housing Fund ... by Editorial Board

Final Hurdle Cleared for Algae Harvesters at Lake Agawam

The final hurdle standing in the way of green-lighting an algae harvester project at Lake ... by Cailin Riley

Eastport Tobacco Shop Closed After Illicit Cannabis Raid; Employee Arrested

Suffolk County Police arrested the employee of an Eastport tobacco shop last week for illegally ... by Staff Writer

April Express Sessions Will Focus on Pros and Cons of Historic District Expansion in Southampton Village

The delicate push and pull between preservation and property rights is familiar to many East End homeowners, as well as local government officials, and it’s an issue that’s been a particular flashpoint in Southampton Village recently. An analysis of a proposed historic district expansion in Southampton Village will be the topic of discussion for the next Express Sessions panel discussion, set for Thursday, April 10, from noon until 2 p.m. at Union Burger Bar at 40 Bowden Square in Southampton Village. The village received a $40,000 Certified Local Government Historic Preservation Grant from the state last fall to study the ... by Cailin Riley

Hampton Bays Cannabis Shop Roils Residents Right out of Gate

With objections to a proposal to open a pot shop in a former bank building ... by Michael Wright

Proposed Westhampton Beach Village Budget Would Increase Taxes by 9 Percent, Piercing State Tax Cap

The Westhampton Beach Village Board is poised to adopt a $14.4 million fiscal year 2025-26 ... by Bill Sutton

Southampton Village Union Alleges Mishandling of Sensitive Employee Records

The leadership of the Civil Service Employees Association, the union that represents much of the ... by Cailin Riley

Southampton Town Will Eliminate Red Lights on County Road 39 for Two Weeks as Experiment on Traffic Flow

Southampton Town will expand its “cops and cones” traffic management efforts with a novel experiment ... by Michael Wright