Tintle's Goal Gives East Hampton Field Hockey Much-Needed Victory Over Pierson/Bridgehampton

icon 19 Photos
East Hampton junior goalie Caeleigh Schuster comes out to deny Pierson senior Bella Eldridge. MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton junior goalie Caeleigh Schuster comes out to deny Pierson senior Bella Eldridge. MARIANNE BARNETT

MARIANNE BARNETT

MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton senior Kerri O'Donnell   MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton senior Kerri O'Donnell MARIANNE BARNETT

The Bonackers celebrate a goal.  MARIANNE BARNETT

The Bonackers celebrate a goal. MARIANNE BARNETT

The Bonackers are all smiles after their 2-1 victory over visiting Pierson/Bridgehampton on Friday. MARIANNE BARNETT

The Bonackers are all smiles after their 2-1 victory over visiting Pierson/Bridgehampton on Friday. MARIANNE BARNETT

Steve Kenny is celebrated along with Georgia and Carly Kenny.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Steve Kenny is celebrated along with Georgia and Carly Kenny. MARIANNE BARNETT

Ava Tintle leads her mother and father in Senior Day festivities on Friday.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Ava Tintle leads her mother and father in Senior Day festivities on Friday. MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton field hockey celebrated its seniors on Friday.   MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton field hockey celebrated its seniors on Friday. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson senior Bella Eldridge moves the ball down the field on her stick.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson senior Bella Eldridge moves the ball down the field on her stick. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson senior Bella Eldridge denies East Hampton freshman Ava Tintle.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson senior Bella Eldridge denies East Hampton freshman Ava Tintle. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson sophomore Ashley Stuckart brings the ball down the field.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson sophomore Ashley Stuckart brings the ball down the field. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson junior Cali Wilson goes to send in a ball.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson junior Cali Wilson goes to send in a ball. MARIANNE BARNETT

The Whalers celebrate the first goal of the game by Shelby Casey.   MARIANNE BARNETT

The Whalers celebrate the first goal of the game by Shelby Casey. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge sends in a corner.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge sends in a corner. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson eighth-grader Sophia Perri kicks the ball out of her defensive zone.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson eighth-grader Sophia Perri kicks the ball out of her defensive zone. MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson senior Bella Eldridge moves the ball down the field on her stick.   MARIANNE BARNETT

Pierson senior Bella Eldridge moves the ball down the field on her stick. MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle moves with the ball.  MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle moves with the ball. MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle. MARIANNE BARNETT

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle. MARIANNE BARNETT

Kerri O'Donnell and her father Damien were among those celebrated during Bonac's Senior Day on Friday.  MARIANNE BARNETT

Kerri O'Donnell and her father Damien were among those celebrated during Bonac's Senior Day on Friday. MARIANNE BARNETT

Drew Budd on Oct 15, 2024

Ava Tintle’s goal just a few minutes into the fourth quarter gave the East Hampton field hockey team a 2-1 lead that held up in what was a much-needed victory over Pierson/Bridgehampton on Friday.

With the win, the Bonackers kept their playoff chances alive with three games remaining on the schedule. After playing at Miller Place on Tuesday, results of which occurred too late to appear in this week’s issue, East Hampton is scheduled to host East Islip this Thursday, October 17, at 4 p.m., before closing out the regular season on Saturday, October 19, at Comsewogue at noon.

East Hampton head coach Danielle Schuster said that after Friday’s win improved her team’s record to 7-6, now just a single win should get her team into the Suffolk County Class B playoffs.

“We’ve got three big games coming up … none of them are givens so these girls are going to have to dig hard, keep up that intensity,” she said. “They can do it.”

While Division II seems to be a bit top heavy this season, with five teams having won 10 or more games already, Schuster conversely said each one of those teams does have a loss this season, some multiple losses, and the recent past has shown that anyone can be beaten.

“You just never know,” she said. “Any given day, whoever comes with the most grit, the most heart, can pull it out. There have been games this year where teams have been toppled. Bayport-Blue Point just took down Harborfields. Last year, we took down Shoreham when it was undefeated. So there’s a lot of back and forth and you can’t take any team for granted.”

Since that’s the case, the girls are just looking to get into the playoffs and take things from there.

“We need a foot in the door,” Shuster said. “We would like more than a foot in the door, but hopefully we’ll be able to.”

Tintle scored what wound up being the game-winning goal on Friday off of a play that was set up off a penalty corner. The senior said junior Hailey Welsch had a good read on the play, in which she saw no defense around Tintle, so she passed her the ball and tried to direct the pass into the goal as best she could.

On top of it being a key game, it was also Senior Day for East Hampton, so the team honored all nine upperclassmen just prior to the start of the game. Tintle has been on the team since her freshman year.

“The team has changed a lot, but I think this year is really special since we’re all very close in age, so our team really gels,” she said. “Today, we put it together … it’s really awesome.”

East Hampton trailed early on, when Pierson senior Cali Wilson sent a ball to goal from about 20 yards out, which junior Shelby Casey was able to get a stick on and deflect into the goal with 6:03 remaining in the first quarter. Pierson head coach Laura DeSario said the long send-in from Wilson had been something her team had been working on, and it worked to near perfection early on in the game.

“We’ve been working on just staying low, keeping our sticks in the circle so that they could get those balls,” she said. “Cali has a tremendous hit, whether she’s sending it up the field or sending it across the field. So we were looking to capitalize on that in the circle. And with [East Hampton junior goalie] Caeleigh Schuster, you have to. You can’t just send it right at the goal. She’s going to stop it.”

The Whalers led, 1-0, for much of the game, until Tintle found fellow senior Addison Barletta, who finally broke through for Bonac with a goal with 18.1 seconds left in the third quarter.

Barletta was down by the left post when Tintle sent the ball toward the goal. Barletta tipped it in, she said.

“I just wanted to get it in the circle,” Tintle said of the play. “I know Addi has a really good stick, so if I could get it in she would get it in the goal.”

“It was a relief,” to score, Barletta added, with a smile.

Barletta is in her second year on varsity and said there was an adjustment period making the jump last year from junior varsity.

“It’s been a lot of fun playing with all of my friends this year,” she said.

Being one of the smallest schools in Division II, there aren’t a ton of “easy” games, but the Whalers’ final third of their schedule is particularly tough. Prior to playing East Hampton on Friday, Pierson played Miller Place and East Islip, which are a combined 20-5 so far this season. They finish up against West Babylon, Shoreham-Wading River and Eastport-South Manor this week.

DeSario said playing the bigger, deeper teams can be tough for her team since it doesn’t have a ton of depth. That was clearly evident on Friday, when the Whalers started the game with just two players on their bench, until about five minutes into the game, when four players came running onto the field from the parking lot. DeSario said those players were on a school trip and took a special train back from the city. A parent picked them up from the Ronkonkoma train station to get them to the game.

“They’ve been playing with a lot of heart,” she said of her team. “It’s hard because they don’t have a deep bench, so their legs are going for the full hour of the game. That’s something we’ve been working on all season, trying to keep that intensity up all game and they’ve been getting better with it. Fourth quarter was a good fight, just didn’t come out on top.”

All of that being said, Pierson is the clear favorite to win the Suffolk County Class C Championship this season, barring any major setbacks, which would make it the program’s 10th straight.

“We’ve been pretty — knock on wood — healthy this season, so hoping to keep that going,” DeSario sad. “Our goal has been to get 1 percent better every day, so that’s what we keep working on, breaking it down to the little things.”

You May Also Like:

Pierson/Bridgehampton Field Hockey's Streak of Consecutive County Titles Comes to an End After Loss to Bayport-Blue Point

For a decade, the Pierson/Bridgehampton field hockey team reaching, and winning, the Suffolk County Class ... 5 Nov 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Pierson/Bridgehampton Field Hockey, Southampton Girls Volleyball Gear Up for Playoffs; Hampton Bays Football Defeats Center Moriches; Rare Home Finale Loss for Hurricane Football

Whalers Field Hockey
To Vie for 11th Consecutive Title The Pierson/Bridgehampton field hockey team has qualified for the Suffolk County Class C Championship, which will be played at Rocky Point High School on Tuesday, November 4, at 6 p.m., or shortly following the preceding Class B Championship. The Whalers, who earned the berth into the championship after going 6-10 in a mixed-classification Division II, will play top-seeded Bayport-Blue Point, which finished the season tied with Class B Eastport-South Manor atop the division with identical 14-1 records. Pierson and Bayport played each other once this season, in Bayport, on September 25. The ... 28 Oct 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson/Bridgehampton Field Hockey Turning Things On in Time for Playoff Push

The Pierson/Bridgehampton field hockey team is gaining steam at just the right time. After losing ... 15 Oct 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Soccer, Westhampton Beach Girls Soccer Earn First Wins; Southampton Field Hockey Defeats West Babylon

Calle’s Hat Trick Leads to
Bonac Boys Soccer First Win The East Hampton boys soccer team defeated Huntington, 6-3, at home on October 8 for their first victory of the season. Eduardo Calle scored a hat trick and had an assist, while Esteban Diaz scored two goals and assisted on two others. Bryan Pillco scored the other goal for the Bonackers (1-10-2 overall) and Adrian Arango made five saves in goal. Bonac Boys Volleyball
Defeats Central Islip The East Hampton boys volleyball team took down Central Islip in three straight sets, 25-17, 25-9, 25-13. The Bonackers are 4-5 overall. Strong Second Half
for ... by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Golf Hands Westhampton Beach Its First Loss; Pierson Boys Soccer, Field Hockey Earn First Wins; Alvarez's Two Goals Lead Mariner Boys Soccer

East Hampton Boys Golf Hand ’Canes Their First Loss Charlie McMillan shot a match-low 33 to help lead the Bonackers to a 7.5-1.5 victory over previously unbeaten Westhampton Beach at the Amagansett Golf Club on Monday. East Hampton outshot the Hurricanes, 199-208. Zach Berger shot a team-low 38 for the ’Canes. Though both teams still had to finish out the rest of their regular season schedules this week, if they win out, East Hampton and Westhampton Beach will share the League VIII title this season. Bonac Swimmers Lose Tight Meet to Ward Melville Down two points going into the final event, ... 8 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Early Lapse Doesn't Hurt Bonac Girls Swimmers; Hampton Bays Girls Volleyball Back in Win Column; Paga's Header Leads Hurricane Boys Soccer To Big Win

East Hampton Field Hockey
Stops Losing Streak Merritt Bistrian-Emptage had a goal and an assist and Sabrina Texis added a goal to lead East Hampton (4-5 in Division II) to a 2-0 victory over Southampton at the Hon. Fred W. Thiele Jr. Recreational Facility on Stephen Hand’s Path on Thursday, September 25, snapping what had been a three-game losing streak. Brynley Lys added an assist and Izzy Briand made two saves in goal. Alexis Trotman made six saves for Southampton. Despite Early Troubles
Bonac Swimmers 
Win Another Meet The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton girls swim team defeated Northport/Commack, 99-69, in their final nonleague meet ... 30 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Pierson/Bridgehampton Field Hockey Adapts to Tough Schedule Against Larger Schools

Through six games, as of the morning of Thursday, September 25, the Pierson/Bridgehampton field hockey ... 23 Sep 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Football Avenges Last Year's Playoff Loss at Hills West; Cook Leads Mariners Cross Country to First Win; Hampton Bays Girls Soccer Tallies Two Wins

Bonac Football Avenges
Last Year’s Playoff Loss The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton football team defeated host Half Hollow Hills West, 35-10, on Saturday afternoon, on the same field the Bonackers suffered a 52-6 loss in the opening round of the Suffolk County Division III playoffs last season. Theo Ball threw for 190 yards and three touchdowns, one of them to Jackson Ronick who also rushed for 75 yards and two touchdowns. Charlie Stern caught three receptions for 115 yards and recorded six tackles on defense. Livs Kuplins had six tackles and an interception and caught a 25-yard reception for a touchdown for the ... by Staff Writer

Pierson Field Hockey Eyes 11th Straight County Title, but Bayport Could Stand in Its Way

The Pierson/Bridgehampton field hockey team has won 10 straight Suffolk County Class C Championships, but ... 27 Aug 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson, Bridgehampton Student-Athletes Earn Postseason Awards for Efforts During Fall Season

Pierson Boys Cross Country All-Division Edmar Gonzalez-Nateras, David Kriegsman Both Gonzalez-Nateras and David Kriegsman each qualified for the New York State Cross Country Championships. — Ed First Team All-League Edmar Gonzalez-Nateras Second Team All-League Ben and David Kriegsman, Ben Ezier Pierson Girls Cross Country All-State, Class C/D Individual County Champion, All-County Greylynn Guyer All-League Bennett Greene, Maggie Greenwald, Greylynn Guyer, Josie Mott The girls went undefeated (6-0) in all League IX dual meets to win the league title outright. Greenwald, Guyer, Mott and Sara O’Brien each qualified individually for the New York State Cross Country Championships. — Ed. Pierson Field ... 26 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer