Walter James Mack, M.D., of Southampton, Westhampton Beach and Hope Town, Bahamas Dies April 17

icon 1 Photo
Walter James Mack

Walter James Mack

author27east on Apr 20, 2021

Walter James Mack, M.D., of Southampton, Westhampton Beach and Hope Town, Bahamas, died at his home, surrounded by family, on April 17. He was 90.

Dr. Mack was a graduate of Niagara University and New York Medical College and, in 1992, was named a Fellow in the American College of Radiology. After graduating from medical school, he served eight years in the U.S. Navy, achieving the rank of Lieutenant Commander.

In 1964, Dr. Mack moved his family to Westhampton Beach and joined the Practice of Radiological Health Services at Southampton Hospital, Central Suffolk Hospital, and Eastern Long Island Hospital. In 1974, he became chief of radiology at Southampton Hospital, where he continued until his retirement in 1999.

Dr. Mack was an accomplished pioneer in medicine. Under his leadership, multiple innovative diagnostic modalities were brought to the community of Southampton, including one of the first CAT scan machines in Suffolk County, real time ultrasound, and dedicated mammography. His efforts led to Southampton Hospital’s establishment of the Breast Center. In spite of his many accomplishments, Dr. Mack was known for being humble, as evidenced by as his fond recollection of his kindergarten teacher, who, he said, liked him so much that, “She had me stay with her for a second year.”

In his youth, Dr. Mack was a collegiate swimmer at Niagara University and a Jones Beach lifeguard in the summers. With friends, he was often referred to as “Cap’t Jim” as he held a 100-ton USCG captain’s license. He was one of the first windsurfers on the East Coast of the U.S. He competed in windsurfing regattas throughout the 1970s, and from 1975-1978 held the East Coast Windsurfer championship. Upon winning, he would downplay it saying “well the other two guys fell off their boards.”

Upon retirement, Dr. Mack and his wife, Fay, lived aboard their trawler seven months of the year cruising from Sag Harbor to Hope Town. He was a member of the Sag Harbor Yacht Club, the Royal Marsh Harbor Yacht Club, and the Hope Town Sailing Club.

Dr. Mack was editor and publisher of the Hope Town Harbor Rats Rag, or “As The Lighthouse Turns,” a spoof of the live-aboards’ of Hope Town Harbor. His writings were noticed by the local Writers Circle and, with prodding and an engraved invitation, he joined their group to became one of their star writers. His short stories of life aboard their trawler, Wanderer, left his audience in tears of laughter. Dr. Mack was the cook aboard the boat and for three years in a row, he came in first place in Hope Town’s annual Chili Contest, competing with local restaurant chefs.

Dr. Mack met his wife, Fay Rhodes, 75 years ago when they were teenagers in Baldwin, New York. They married in 1954 and were blissfully attached at the hip.

In addition to his wife, he is survived by their five “rotten children” and their saintly spouses: Dr. Barbara Mack and Anthony Johnson, Jimmy Mack and Brian Mott, Tom and Tara Mack, Billy and Leslie Mack, Nancy Mack and Chad Smith; 11 grandchildren, Lauren Chu, Christen Chu, Fay Chu, Alec Chu, TylerAnn Mack, JordanRose Mack, James Mack, Will Mack, Cole Smith, Beckett Smith and Dashiell Smith. Dr. Mack was predeceased by his nephew, Kurt Bohn; and his sister, Mary Lou Gavin.

Though kind, compassionate, and encouraging as a husband, father, and grandfather, his greatest accomplishment, according to his family, was summed up in these five words upon his retirement: Proud To Be Mister Fay.

Per “Mr. Fay’s” wishes, his family said, there will be no service and no flowers. He would wish friends to devote their resources and time to their families, his family said, noting that Dr. Mack agreed to the family’s wishes for a celebration of his life later this summer, of which he said, “he would love to join,” and would attend in spirit.

You May Also Like:

A Surprise Every Morning: Sunrises Are Southampton Photographer's Specialty, and He Shares Them Daily on Instagram

Every day he’s in Southampton, Eric Nastri does the same exact thing. And yet, he ... 4 Dec 2025 by Cailin Riley

Southampton Turns Back to Outside Help To Stay Ahead of Building Application Deluge

Southampton Town has renewed a contract with a freelance building plans examiner to keep up ... by Michael Wright

Ground Broken for Westhampton Community Center; Long-Awaited Resource Could Open in 2026

Southampton Town officials held a ceremonial groundbreaking on the long-awaited Westhampton Community Center project on ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of December 4

SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — Matthew Kopoulos, 34, of East Hampton was arrested by Village Police on December 2 and charged with petit larceny and unlawfully fleeing an officer, both misdemeanors, stemming from a September 25 incident in which police say Kopoulos stole items from the 7-Eleven on North Sea Road and then fled the scene on an e-bike. When a Village Police officer attempted to stop him he sped away and drove onto the Shinnecock Territory. A village officer recognized Kopoulos walking on the side of Tuckahoe Road this week and placed him under arrest. He was arraigned in Village Justice ... by Staff Writer

Love in Action

On behalf of the Hamptons United Methodist Church, I would like to extend our heartfelt thanks to the generous donors and dedicated volunteers who made this year’s free community Thanksgiving dinner a remarkable success. Because of your kindness, we were able to serve nearly 500 of our neighbors — families, seniors, workers and individuals from all walks of life — by providing a holiday meal for their table. For the sixth year in a row, we are also deeply indebted to our fearless leader, Denise Smith-Meacham. To our volunteers: You peeled and chopped and cooked, packaged and delivered meals, washed ... by Staff Writer

A Day of Quiet

November 27, Thursday, Thanksgiving Day. Morning: I hear the screech owl, the great-horned owl, the Cooper’s hawk, Carolina wren, white-throated sparrow, chirps of the cardinal, red-breasted nuthatch, the cooo of the mourning dove; songs of rooster, flicker, dark-eyed junco. Titmouse, blue jay. Wind, barely a breeze, whispers haaaaaaaa in wind language, lovingly. Tranquility. Peace. I’m alive — ping of chill in the air, my skin zings. This sacred silence is why I moved here 40 years ago. But it’s completely gone now. And why? Was our designation of “green community” just a photo-op? A lie? Words co-opted like the phrase ... by Staff Writer

White House Confidential

There has been some consternation expressed about changes that the Trump administration is making to the White House, including the East Wing demolition, paving over the Rose Garden, and plans for a grand ballroom. Let’s put some historical perspective on this: The first president to occupy the White House, John Adams, did so 225 years ago last month, and the building and grounds have been undergoing change ever since. Construction of the White House had begun during George Washington’s first term — specifically, at noon on October 13, 1792, with the laying of the cornerstone. The main residence and foundations ... by Tom Clavin

The Nitrogen Threat

“Restore Our Waters” was the title of the invitation. Its subtitle: “Learn How To Switch Out Your Septic To Remove The No. 1 Threat to Groundwater, Nitrogen, From Our Septic Systems With Tax-Free Grant Funds.” Some 100 people packed into the auditorium of the Southampton Cultural Center two weeks ago for a “public education event” to learn about an issue that has deeply impacted Suffolk County: the migration of nitrogen from cesspools into groundwater, the sole source of potable water in Suffolk. The nitrogen also goes into surface waters, including lakes, ponds and bays. Spotlighted at the event was the ... by Karl Grossman

Vigor and Decay

Brown is the color of the days. We, at such an angle to the sun, give up our growing season and must tilt toward the melancholy color of mud. While finger-painting, brown might be the first color you make by mistake. In your enthusiasm, you blended all the colors on the pallet and ended up with nothing remarkable. In fact, it looks like excrement. Brown may not be a vibrant color, but it is generally a warm one. All living things are, at some point, brown. The goldfinch, as if reduced to rags, just dingy fluff where brightness had been. ... by Marilee Foster

Community News, December 4

HOLIDAY HAPPENINGS Santa on the Farm Weekend The Long Island Game Farm invites families to ... by Staff Writer