Westhampton Beach Village Board Gives Thumbs Up To Rogers Avenue Proposal, With Conditions - 27 East

Westhampton Beach Village Board Gives Thumbs Up To Rogers Avenue Proposal, With Conditions

icon 1 Photo
The Westhampton Beach Village Board. EXPRESS FILE

The Westhampton Beach Village Board. EXPRESS FILE

authorBill Sutton on Jun 8, 2022

A proposed multifamily housing development on Rogers Avenue in Westhampton Beach came one step closer to reality this week as the Village Board unanimously approved a special exception permit allowing the proposal to move forward — but not without slightly reducing the size of the project and setting a host of other conditions that must be met by the developer.

Rogers Associates LLC had proposed building a 52-unit townhouse development at the site of a former asphalt plant on Rogers Avenue, including a community center, pool, tennis court and an on-site sewage treatment plant. The developer also requested that a scenic easement deeded to the village along the property line be extinguished.

The village’s Planning Board, following an exhaustive two-year review marked by strong opposition from neighbors of the development site, approved a preliminary site plan in February before kicking the application to the Village Board for the special exception review required to move forward. Following the Village Board approval this week, on June 2, the application will move back to the Planning Board for final site plan review.

But in a nod to the concerns of neighboring homeowners, the Village Board’s conditional approval limited the development to 48 units, a reduction of four units by eliminating one of the proposed 13 housing buildings closest to the neighbors on the southwestern side of the property.

Additionally, the board voted to maintain the scenic easement between the development and its neighbors to maintain a buffer, but will allow the developer to landscape the easement. The board also set guidelines as to the size and scope of affordable units in the development and set up a $25,000 traffic fund, paid by the developer, to mitigate traffic concerns that may result from the increased development.

“Our concern was with the proposed density and the impact it would have on the neighbors and the community as a whole,” Mayor Maria Moore said this week.

The building eliminated from the plan, containing four housing units, as included in the site plan, would have encroached on the scenic easement. By nixing that building from the plan, the board both reduced the project’s density and maintained the easement, which was deeded to the village before the asphalt plant closed in 2005 and the property was rezoned from industrial use to multi-family use.

“The board determined it appropriate to eliminate four units to mitigate the impact of the development and to maintain the scenic easement that had been dedicated to the village years ago,” Moore said. “The board denied the applicant’s request to rescind the scenic easement. We maintained the scenic easement but allowed it to be landscaped, which will provide additional protection to the adjacent property owners.”

Under the developer’s original plan, eight of the condominiums would be three-bedroom units, 36 would be two bedrooms, and eight would be one-bedroom affordable housing units. Under the board’s conditional approval this week, officials stipulated that the bedroom mix of affordable units shall be distributed in the same proportion as market-rate units, and that the size of affordable units shall be substantially identical to the size of market-rate units of the same bedroom count, Moore said.

“For every two units we eliminated, one was required to be a market rate unit and one was required to be an affordable unit,” she said. “The board was faced with balancing its concern over density with the need for affordable housing.”

Board member Brian Tymann said he was happy with outcome of the board’s review of the project and believes that the work of the two village boards will result in a development that will work for the village.

“I think that the project is a good one,” he said. “I also think that it has demonstrated that the village and its boards work very hard to act in the best interest of the community. Some residents of the area may not be happy, but I hope they see that we’ve listened to their concerns and did our absolute best to address them.”

While the density of the proposed project and the effect that would have on the character of the single-family residential neighborhood surrounding it was a major concern of neighbors throughout the Planning Board review process, many neighbors were also anxious about how it would affect traffic in the area — especially since the area has become a cut-through for motorists seeking a shortcut from County Road 31 to Montauk Highway to bypass commuter traffic.

Neighbors told horror stories of cars speeding down Rogers Avenue putting playing children and pets in the area at risk.

Village officials noted at previous meetings that they were aware of the traffic problems and had taken steps to address the issue, most recently by increasing the police presence in the neighborhood and installing radar speed signs to help control traffic.

As part of this week’s special exception approval, the developer will be required to set up a $25,000 traffic fund, to be managed by the village, to help mitigate the traffic.

“My takeaway from day one was that traffic and speed concerns were of utmost importance,” Tymann said. “That has been my focus — to identify the existing issues of speed and safety in that area and not only actively address them, but to avoid them getting worse. Speed humps, signage, a full 90-degree turn at the end of Rogers with a stop sign, increased police presence — I want people to know that Rogers and Hazelwood are residential communities that will not tolerate speeding. In fact, this development could be seen as a wake-up call to the safety issues happening already.”

Moore noted that although traffic studies conducted as part of the Planning Board review did not indicate that the development would create a discernible increase in traffic or speed in the area, the board “responded to the concerns of the neighbors and agreed to implement certain traffic calming measures,” including the electronic speed signs that will not only calm traffic but collect data to give the Village Police a better idea of when to deploy officers to the area for speed enforcement. The village also offered to install speed bumps and signage, she said, noting that the village will seek input from neighbors on what measures to employ.

“The developer offered to pay $25,000 toward the installation of any such traffic calming measures,” she noted.

The project will now go back to the Planning Board for final site plan review, with the conditions set by the Village Board in place.

“The Board of Trustees’ role was limited to providing a determination to the Planning Board after applying the requirements of the code,” Moore said. “The application is now in the hands of the Planning Board to work with the applicant on the layout, drainage, setbacks, etc.”

With the mitigations in place, Tymann said that he believes the project will have a positive impact on the village. “Overall, I think this project will be good for the community and I believe that with the level of scrutiny that the village gave to it,” he said, “the residents in the area and the community as a whole will be happy with it.”

“We did take a careful look and I believe arrived at a decision that struck a line between several differing perspectives on this project that will work for the benefit of community and the village in the long run,” board member Ralph Urban added.

You May Also Like:

The Retreat Calls Attention to Human Trafficking in Light of Alexander Brothers Indictment

The Retreat, an East Hampton-based nonprofit agency that provides services to victims of domestic violence and sexual assault and offers violence prevention community education, is calling attention to sex trafficking and sexual assault on the South Fork in light of the recent indictment of the Alexander brothers. Oren and Tal Alexander, who were luxury real estate brokers in Miami, New York and the Hamptons, and their brother Alon were arrested in December on federal charges of sex trafficking. Authorities described a pattern of sexual abuse spanning more than a decade in which they allegedly lured woman through “deception, fraud and ... 20 Dec 2024 by Staff Writer

Let It Play Out

My response, Harry Mainzer, to your argument that Pete Hegseth is unqualified for nomination and confirmation as secretary of defense is: Let the process play out [“Kakistocracy,” Letters, December 19]. My disagreement with you is primarily with the faceless, anonymous sources that have been used to contaminate the fairness of this nomination. For Donald Trump supporters, it is all too reminiscent of the innuendo, lies and outright subterfuge of the initial Trump presidency by a Democratic Party and its complicit media, which abandoned its journalistic responsibilities to amplify doubt and falsehoods. It is clear that you don’t see it from ... by Staff Writer

Reap Joy

I immersed myself in the Hamptons Doc Fest this December, both as a volunteer and a filmgoer. I hadn’t attended more than a handful of films over the festival’s history, now in its 17th year; however, my recent involvement electrified me with the intoxicating breadth and vitality of this magnificent event! From founder Jacqui Lofaro and her mainstay of directors, to its staff and boards, to its sponsors and patrons, the Hamptons Doc Fest is a hard-driving jubilee rivaling any international film festival. I read a quote that film festivals are “niche businesses.” Upon offering my aid shortly after eye ... by Staff Writer

Unprofessional Tirade

In Shakespeare’s “Hamlet,” Queen Gertrude famously observes, “The lady doth protest too much, methinks,” suggesting that overly forceful denials often reveal a lack of sincerity. This sentiment captures the debacle at the December 12 Southampton Village Board meeting, where Trustee Robin Brown, without being listed on the agenda, commandeered the public’s time with an unprofessional tirade [“Trustee Robin Brown Takes Southampton Village Ethics Board to Task at Meeting,” 27east.com, December 18]. At approximately the 1:05:34 mark, Brown, encouraged by Mayor Bill Manger, interrupted the meeting to launch a seven-minute, misguided attack on the Village Ethics Board, which had found her ... by Staff Writer

Town Accepting Waitlist Applications for Boat Slips

The Southampton Town Parks and Recreation Department is now accepting waitlist lottery applications for slips at Bay Avenue Marina, Beaver Dam Marina, Bishop’s Marina, Conscience Point Marina and Pine Neck Marine Preserve, for the 2025 boating season. Town of Southampton residents or taxpayers who own vessels 45 feet in length or less for Conscience Point Marina, 30 feet in length or less for Pine Neck Marine Preserve and 25 feet in length or less for Bay Avenue Marina, Beaver Dam Marina or Bishop’s Marina may obtain applications by emailing the parks maintenance office at egeorge@southamptontownny.gov or by visiting the town’s ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Village Board Hears Update to Resort Hotel Plans, Adds Clarification to Leaf Blower Ban

During a public hearing at the latest Southampton Village Board meeting on December 12, representatives for Dede Gotthelf, the owner of 71 Hill Street, presented updated and revised plans for a resort hotel that will include several units of workforce housing. The primary feature of the latest revision is the elimination of plans for an indoor pool, which will have the effect of decreasing the overall width of the building and will allow for more green space on the property. The plan will now include an outdoor pool instead. The changes mean the building will now only cover 50 percent ... by Cailin Riley

Southampton DWI Arrests for the Week of December 19

Miguel Lopez Reynoso, 32, of Westhampton Beach was arrested by Westhampton Beach Police on December 11, at 11:23 p.m., and charged with DWI, a misdemeanor. Lopez Reynoso was pulled over at Peters Lane after being observed following too closely behind another vehicle while driving on Montauk Highway, said police. Police said he told them he had only one beer before driving but performed poorly on a field sobriety test. A breath test came up with a reading of 0.13 percent. An investigation revealed that Lopez Reynoso had a prior DWI conviction in April 2023. He was transported to Southampton Town ... 19 Dec 2024 by Staff Writer

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of December 19

WESTHAMPTON BEACH — On December 11 at 5:17 a.m., a 36-year-old Philadelphia man was cited for leaving the scene of an accident with property damage, a violation, after a Westhampton Beach Village Police officer said police observed a downed street sign and then reviewed village cameras, which showed the man had collided with a yield sign at Potunk Lane and Main Street a day earlier. The man stated to police that he was driving an oversized vehicle and was unaware that he had run over the sign. WESTHAMPTON BEACH — On December 11 at 4:49 p.m. Westhampton Beach Village Police ... by Staff Writer

Swords Into Plowshares

It isn’t the first potato truck I learned to drive, but it’s the same kind, a retrofitted army truck, rugged and simple in accord with its unstoppable American design. When the engine cranks and comes to life — as it has for 50 years, and will for 50 more — patriotic old men, many of them farmers, know to thank Detroit. But we’ve sold her. We’re thinning the fleet. A farm in Vermont wants this one. Almost all of our harvest trucks have a military surplus pedigree. With this pedigree comes a year. One of the oldest trucks, one we ... by Marilee Foster

Craig Kruzel of Southampton Dies December 4

Craig Kruzel, a lifelong resident of Southampton, died peacefully in his home on December 4. He was 70. Born April 11, 1954, he was predeceased by his parents, Albert and Stella Kruzel. He is survived by his wife, Sheila; daughter Elyse; sisters Connie and Missy; and niece Emilie and nephew Andrew; as well as their families. A memorial will be held in the spring. by Staff Writer